Sunday, July 19, 2009

somalia thread

some current developments/stories/links i found of interest

there have been reports of ethiopian troop movements again inside somalia, this time reportedly vacating two recent bases

earlier this week

Ethiopian troops move away from Kala-beyrka junction in central Somalia
BELEDWEYN (Sh. M. Network) - the Ethiopian troops in the Kala-beyrka intersection in Hiran region have moved away from their bases there on Thursday morning, witnesses told Shabelle radio on Thursday.

Reports from Hiran region say that the Ethiopian troops were in the junction about two months and completely left from their military bases there in the region and moved to the side of Fer-Fer town in the Somali region in Ethiopia.

The Ethiopian troops arrived there on 19th May 2009 and conducted more search operations in the neighborhoods and the traffic traveling on the road that connects between the towns of the region during their presence there.

It is unclear the reason of the Ethiopian troops' withdrawal from the Kala-bayrka intersection in central Somalia.


and, by saturday

Ethiopian troops vacate in Yed village in southern Somalia
EED (Sh. M. Network) – the Ethiopian troops in Yed village in Bakol region have vacated from there in a southern Somalia, witnesses told Shabelle radio on Saturday.

Residents said that more Ethiopian troops with many battle wagons in Yed village which borders with Ethiopia had completely left their base there in Bakol region in the south of the country.

Locals told reporters that the Ethiopian troops were in parts of the region for several months supporting the transitional government officials who were chased from Bay and Bakol and moved to the side of Barey in the Somali region in Ethiopia.

Reports say that the Ethiopian troops used to support the transitional government officials in Basy and Bakol administrations earlier saying that their withdrawal came as the traditional elders of Bakol region ordered the Ethiopians to the leave from the village quickly.

...

..it is unclear whether the Ethiopian troops left completely or will return back to the region


there have been clashes already in the hiiraan region following their pullout, reportedly initiated by hizbul islam forces




biyokulule online republishes two january 2007 dispatches from the (expensive) private intel newsletter the indian ocean newsletter, citing closed sources, that sure would have come in handy at that time to have had access to. both provide more information on the active roles of the u.s. and kenya during the late-2006 invasion

According to information obtained in Nairobi by The Indian Ocean Newsletter from a Kenyan military intelligence officer, the Ethiopian army had indeed been accompanied by American military advisors when it went into Somalia. One or two advisors were affected to each Ethiopian platoon command and enabled to improve the coordination of the forces combating the Union of Islamic Courts (UIC). These advisors were from the American Special Forces (the Delta Force commandos) under the orders of the Pentagon Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC). They have sophisticated communications equipment enabling them to receive orders from American military vessels sailing off the coast of Somalia. Before the conflict, the military intelligence services of Kenya, Ethiopia and the United States had drawn up a list of the forces, equipment and positions of the UIC militia, which they had tended to overestimate.

Kenya was subsequently the only IGAD country to have advance information of the air raids against the Islamists in south Somalia. American and Kenyan aid, and not only in military intelligence, has been indispensable in ousting the Somalian Islamists from the Ras Kamboni zone where they had taken refuge. After the air raid by an American AC-130, an American Special Forces commando was sent on the ground to support the Ethiopian army. At the same time, the Kenyan air force intervened using unmarked helicopters to oust Islamist militia hidden in the forest around Ras Kamboni. It was then only after a bloody battle that the Ethiopian army managed to defeat the Somalian islamists, by that time completely surrounded.


and

In addition to sealing their border to close the exit door for Unionof Islamic Courts (UIC) militia and Somalian civilians fleeing the combat zone, the Kenyan authorities have provided logistic support to the Ethiopian army and its Somalian and American allies. Kenyan air force planes have regularly flown over the Ras Kamboni region to carry out reconnaissance and surveillance operations of this zone where Islamist militia had taken refuge. Other similar air-borne missions have monitored retreating Islamist militia convoys. The Kenyan military intelligence services passed on these data to their American and Ethiopian counterparts, enabling them to carry out their military operations and air strikes. According to information obtained by The Indian Ocean Newsletter from a military intelligence source based in Nanyuki, a Kenyan helicopter flying over the Ras Kamboni region last week near the border town of Hulugho was fired on by Somalian Islamist militia using light arms.

Two other Kenyan helicopters in the same zone were also fired on and the windshield of one of them was hit. On 9 January Kenyan helicopters participated in an air raid against Somalian Islamists in Hayi. A ground fight also took place around Amuna between Kenyan soldiers and Somalian Islamists who were trying to cross the border. The Kenyan ministry of defence sent reinforcements to the border crossing points at Amuna, Liboi and Hulugho. Newsflash alert sent to subscribers on 16.1.2007.The Kenyan government has given strict instructions that no information on Kenya`s direct involvement in this conflict should be leaked to the press. The Kenyan military intelligence services have also asked Kenyan diplomats to deny reports that a rocket from an Ethiopian aircraft aimed at a column of Islamists in the South of Somalia had crashed into Kenyan territory.





minnesota public radio: Rep. Ellison says U.S. trying to ensure safe return of missing Somalis
St. Paul, Minn. — Minnesota Congressman Keith Ellison said the U.S. government is trying to ensure the safe return of some of the young Somali-American men believed to be fighting with a terrorist group in their homeland.

Ellison said he has been included in classified briefings about efforts to bring the missing men back to the Twin Cities.

...

Ellison wouldn't offer more details of the plans, saying the discussions were classified. But he said the efforts involve private non-governmental organizations as well as government entities. A State Department official did not respond to requests for interviews.


more spying by the INGO's in somalia is not likely to help anyone




latest analysis from prof weinstein covers events from mid-june thru july 14, focusing on the lack of enthusiasm to respond to the TFG2's pleas for direct international intervention to save their butts. and elaborates on a point i made recently in the previous incarnation of africa comments as to why there is int'l interest in keeping the islamists preoccupied w/ fighting each other

Desperate Call and Supporter's Compromised Response
What is clear is that Somalia’s neighbors appear genuinely to view the gains of the opposition as threats to their security; they are fearful of the Islamist opposition taking over southern and central Somalia, particularly if it results in an “emirate” established by the transnationalist Salafist al-Shabaab movement. The armed opposition, whether transnationalist or nationalist, has ultimate irredentist aims to incorporate ethnic Somali populations in Ethiopia, Kenya and Djibouti into a greater Somali state. It is the threat of irredentism, although it is presently remote; concern for the possibility of ethnic Somali unrest within their borders aided and abetted by Islamists; and vulnerability to terrorist acts that are responsible for I.G.A.D.’s position and appeal. Only Somalia’s neighbors, among the external actors, have such perceived vital interests.





here's some very relevant background material on int'l efforts, in this case intervention by the cia, to shape somalia's governance in the effort to head off irrendentist threats to the region. this is taken from a 2005 Roobdoon Forum analysis. (see the original for footnotes)



In September 1974, a conference held in Washington, sponsored by the Center for the National Security Studies was presented proceedings and papers on the subject of “The CIA and Covert Action”. Roger Morris and Richard Mauzy presented a comprehensive piece of research which is, as they state, based on both written sources and many oral conversations that they had with US decision-makers and foreign policy officials who supplied them many of their research discourse [4]. The title of their research paper is: Following the Scenario: Reflection on Five Case Histories in the Mode and Aftermath of CIA Intervention.

Morris and Mauzy unveil that the U. S. Central Intelligence Agency had been clandestinely funneling mainly a financial support to the political actors in Somalia since mid 1960s, in an effort to ward off Somali Weyn tendencies inside top brass leadership. In 1967 election campaigns, for example, the CIA provided thousands of dollars to assist in the election of the Prime late Prime Minister Mohamed Haji Ibrahim Egal and some of his fellow Somali Youth League (SYL) members. Here is a selection from Morris and Mauzy’s case history of CIA ‘campaign of financing’ in the 1967 Somali elections:



An impoverished land of less than three million along the northeastern coast of Africa where the Indian Ocean meets the Gulf of Aden, Somalia was of concern to Washington for a number of reasons. Irredentist claims threatened border warfare with both Kenya and Ethiopia, the latter a long-time U.S. client state under Haile Selassie and the site of a major intelligence base. Somalia was also an early recipient of Soviet aid in Africa, and its coastline held potentially strategic ports for any future rivalry in the Persian Gulf or Indian Ocean, an interest shared by France and Britain. At that, however, the country was apparently not an urgent concern in U.S. diplomacy. When Somalia predictably rejected a 1963 American offer of "defensive" arms, conditioned on the exclusion of all other supplies, the State Department leaked its "displeasure" but seemingly did no more.

Over the next four years, 1963-1967, official U.S.-Somali relations were distant and U.S. aid next to nothing while Somali leaders visited the Soviet bloc, Somali newspapers published anti-American forgeries planted by Soviet intelligence, and the country fought a brief but bloody border war with Ethiopia. Then suddenly, early in 1967, history took a turn for the better. President Abd-i-Rashid Shermarke was elected for a six-year term as President in June and in July appointed as Premier Muhammad Egal, American-educated and avowedly pro-Western. By fall, U.S. aid was resumed in amounts twice the previous total since independence, and Somalia had concluded a border agreement with Ethiopia [see the footnote to read the 1967-68 Somali Border Agreements with Ethiopia and Kenya] [5]. In 1968 Egal visited the United States, following a visit to Somalia by Vice President Humphrey, and was hailed by President Johnson as "enormously constructive in a troubled area of Africa." What the two leaders did not discuss, say official sources, was how "constructive" the CIA had been for Mr. Egal, whose rise, to power was reportedly facilitated by thousands of dollars in covert support to Egal and other pro-Western elements in the ruling Somali Youth League party prior to the 1967 Presidential election.

In retrospect, this clandestine bankrolling in Somalia seems very modest by CIA standards, only a tiny fraction of what the Agency has spent in a month in Southeast Asia or even what it spent in the Congo in the early sixties. And its immediate benefits - in rising U.S. influence, in the detente with a grateful Ethiopia - no doubt seemed real enough at the time. In any event, several sources say the subsidies were discontinued in 1968. But the withdrawal was to be perhaps too late. On October 15, 1969, while Egal was again visiting the United States, President Shermarke was assassinated. A week later the Army seized power, dissolving the National Assembly and Constitution and arresting the entire Cabinet, including Egal. Among the charges against Egal would be corruption of the electoral process and complicity with foreign intelligence services. Ironically, the bizarre CIA political contributions before 1967 may have been a decisive factor in the eventual fall of the Agency's candidate [6].



Reflecting the unwise decisions made by the CIA about its covert political interventions and subsidies, Premier Egal’s government lasted less than three years. In October 21st 1969, a military led coup d'état replaced the civilian government, detaining and charging (as mentioned above) the civilian Prime Minister of ‘complicity with foreign intelligence’. The military men have actually spoiled the CIA agenda – whether this was also instance of complicity of another foreign factor/s or genuine local revolutionary respond that vehemently opposed to the unfolding scenarios of border agreements, is debatable. However, one thing was sure: the military takeover was a bloodless transition that succeeded to frustrate the pro-American elements in the country and ended the American subsidiary civilian government. Italian writer, Luigi Pestalozza, who observed and recorded the early unfolding events of the Somali military Revolution states that “No tears were shed for the men who thus left the stage forever, disappearing from the [political] history of Somalia [7].”




shermarke's son, of course, is now PM for the latest engineered govt after relocating to mogadishu from virginia. and when not in mogadishu, he can usually be contacted thru the u.s. embassy in nairobi

9 comments:

Maxcrat said...

Thanks for the updates.

How likely is it that the Islamic Courts Union and other parts of the opposition could present a united front and common terms for negotiating a constructive resolution to this if the AU, U.N., EU or U.S. were to seriously pursue it?

Is it realistic to think that the opposition would allow AQ to function within Somalia if they regained power?

b real said...

maxcrat -

the likelihood of another unified front right now of the magnitude that the earlier ICU had appears rather slim.

the ICU itself fractured into a number of different factions and new alignments. not all are part of the opposition, as several figures, including sheikh sharif himself, are now co-opted into their former enemy, the so-called 'transitional federal govt', after sharif was peeled off from the ARS in asmara.

hizbul islam was one attempt to join several of the current opposition militias under a unified group, and it has been moderately succesful, though undermined by internal disputes early on & unable to convince the decentralized harakat al shabaab mujahideen militias that a unified front was in the best interests of all. part of this is due to broader ideological differences, according to some observers, which override any exigent opportunities to coalesce around common objective. there does appear to be coordination of activities, after all they are often end up fighting side by side to control/retake territories & fend off attacks, but nothing more than transitory at this point.

and even if hizbul islam & harakat al shabaab mujahideen were to unite, it is extremely unlikely that they would be recognized as a legitimate negotiating force. they have repeatedly, despite official rhetoric indicating otherwise, been rejected any opportunity for a seat at the table in any official discussions. instead there is a continued demonization of them as extremists who have no say in imposing their "foreign" ideals of islam on somalia, while, in actuality, it is a continuation of a homegrown revolutionary islamic mvmt that resulted in the courts themselves back in '06.

simply put, as we see elsewhere in the political arena, only those muslims deemed "moderate", meaning compatible w/ western hegemonic criteria, are tolerable in positions of power to those who want to shape the world to their advantage.

re exaggerated the tales of al-qa'idah seeking a safe haven in somalia, don't take them too seriously. the opposition, supported widely in southern and central somalia, is fighting against foreign control of their country.

Maxcrat said...

Thanks for such a comprehensive reply. I guess the U.S. government is happier providing tepid lip service-style support to a weak TFG than to look to some coalition of resistance forces for a constructive negotiated resolution that would involve disengagement. I'm not exactly surprised, but continually disappointed.

xcroc said...

I echo Maxcrat, not exactly surprised and continually disappointed. For many years, every time the US got a new president I used to think maybe the foreign policy would get a bit smarter, or at least take a longer view of self interest. I'd still like to see it.

Meanwhile, a bit farther south, Bunyoro king flees as police besiege palace. I just stumbled on this. It appears to be some conflict between the King and the Resident District Commissioner, Ms Martha Asimwe, and involve an armed robbery. Oil isn't mentioned, but I wonder about it lurking in the background.

And apparently the Obama visit to Ghana caused some friction with Togo.
Ghana-Togo Relationship In Crisis Over Obama Trip
The much-touted US President Barack Obama’s visit to Ghana has left a looming international relations crisis in its wake, with a Togolese private newspaper warning of a possible return to cold, hurtful diplomatic relations between Togo and Ghana.

This follows an alleged secret meeting between Togolese opposition leader, Gilchrist Olympio and President Barack Obama, purportedly arranged by the Ghanaian authorities in Accra.
...
According to the paper, the Togolese opposition leader was virtually given a red carpet treatment in Accra and invited to the Ghanaian Parliament where the American President gave an address.
... opposition leader was accorded the privilege of engaging Barack Obama in a few minutes’ tete-a-tete, albeit briefly, during the visit to Accra.
...
And all this was done when negotiations for a high-powered Togo government delegation to be allowed to meet President Obama in Accra was turned down by Ghana, the paper alleged. Viewed against the background that a semblance of a reconciliatory process was organized between Accra and Lome recently, the Togolese government saw the development as unfortunate and an act of betrayal.


I really don't know the truth or significance of this. It may just be a private paper with an axe to grind. As I understand it Gilchrist Olympio lives some of the time in Ghana. It sounds like a much more political act than President Obama seems to prefer.

xcroc

b real said...

i apologize for the glaring typos in my response

should have read "despite official rhetoric claiming otherwise", not 'indicating'

and, of course, "the exaggerated tales" not 'exaggerated the tales'

in too much of a hurry on too little sleep these days

maxcrat - the u.s., as i've long been pointing out, provides much more than just "tepid lip service-style support" for the TFG. maybe someday i'll attempt to outline all that we've observed, but, for now, there were efforts to build up credibility for the former TFG through 'national reconciliation conferences' which went nowhere due to the power & popularity of the insurgency and president yusuf's administration's intransigence. so the transitional federal charter was adjusted, things moved to djibouti, and, in what has to be viewed as a counter-revolutionary strategy, a compromise was reached w/ the most compromised wing of the ARS. the pliable sheikh sharif was made president, islamist is now fighting islamist, with a little help from uganda & burundi, and that's just the way the external powers seem to like it. they'll throw in just enough money & arms & training to ensure somalia stays destabilized so long as there's the threat of a radicalized islamic revolution in the region.

xcroc - thanks. certainly is interesting timing for the king of bunyoro to be vacating his throne

b real said...

mareeg online: Rebel leader says he is uniting Insurgents
MOGADISHU (Mareeg)—Somalia’s rebel leader Sheik Hassan Dahir Aweys said on Friday plans to unite Hizbul Islam-his group and al Shabaab were going on.

Addressing hundreds of people in Aba Hureyra Mosque in Bakaraha market in Mogadishu after Friday’s prayers Sheik Hassan Dahir Aweys said people should be patient the casualties from the fighting and wait what he called “victory over enemies”.

b real said...

from the latest analysis piece from abdikarim haji abdi buh, sharif's ambivalent state of mind - flee or not to flee is the question, posted at wardheer news

[blockquote]

The recent consignment of 40-ton pile of guns and ammunition from the United States not from Eretaria ended up at the weapons and ammunitions market faster then the expectation of the market merchants which angered them to a point they knock at the door of the Shar – Sharif’s door. They complained about the flooding of their market which is distorting the demand and supply of the market and asked for compensation for the lost investments. The uniform was the only well come as it found a readily demand from the city’s restaurant workers, wheel barrow market porters and also from the labourers in the building trade and etc. Disappointed arms dealers which are based near Black Sea restaurant- Cirka Toogte, are selling the M16 ,version known as Saar, at lost to get rid of it as fast as it pushed its way in to the market to avoid further price buckle.

The stock of arms and ammunitions in the market was predictable at best of times because there was only one source of supply – Ethiopian government. The market has to adjust itself in anticipation of further floods of arms from USA and hopefully from other European countries which will certainly drive the prices down unless new inter- tribal wars or inter-Islamists wars come to the rescue of the market. It is plausible possibility that the insiders of the market might work out to start low intensity wars between Mogadishu tribes to take the excess out of the market - the end justifies the means.

The TFG soldiers deposit their ammunition with the ladies that sell QAT in and around the vicinity of the old National Theatre to sell for them and that practices were going on for a long time.

...

The opposition Islamists are rightly bent on taking out their ex - comrade in arms who blatantly betrayed them at the behest of the CIA and I do firmly believe that Shar - Sharif should know the basic laws of politics – political mistake committed can only be corrected by blood path. His past is haunting him but it is a high time to understand that he can’t buy one more day by accusing his comrades as being terrorists – how come he is not one when he is fanning the fires of un-winnable war at colossal civilian cost. He can’t repay the human and material catastrophe he enacted during his short term in the fictitious office but can mitigate by accepting defeat and leaving the scene for the Somalis to start the second round, of what ever, sooner then latter.

I sense the second round is inevitable and is round the corner but will start in earnest soon after Shar – Sharif is hanged or crosses the boarder to the safety of where his money is stashed. The Islamists will definitely fight among themselves as their creed differs greatly – Al-Shabab on one side of the scale and Hisbi – Islam on the other side. I foresee that their scuffle will not create civilian casualties of the proportion we have seen because foreign forces with heavy but blind guns will be denied the theatre of war by both and the discipline of their soldiers and fighters guarantees maximum safety and security to civilians unlike the current TFG bandits( mooryaan). As they stand to day the area under the control of the Mujahidiin in Mogadishu as well as in the rest of the country, the civilians can sleep in their homes without the need to close their doors – they delivered water tight law and order at avoidable price and as such they deserve to be praised and encouraged.

[/blockquote]

b real said...

garowe online: 'Ethiopia troops return' to key road in central Somalia
[blockquote]

BELETWEIN, Somalia July 25 (Garowe Online) - A heavily armed convoy of Ethiopian troops has returned to a key road in central Somalia, Radio Garowe reports.

Witnesses and local sources reported that the Ethiopian army convoy crossed the common border and arrived at Kala-Beyr junction in the central Hiran region on Saturday morning.

Kala-Beyr is a strategic crossroads that connects the central regions and the northern of Somalia and provides access to the Somali-inhabited region of eastern Ethiopia.

Ethiopian troops had withdrawn from Kala-Beyr junction earlier this month and it was not immediately clear whey the troops returned.

But their return comes at a time when two consecutive days of fighting among Islamist militias in parts of Hiran and Galgadud regions killed at least 31 people, according to local sources.

[/blockquote]

b real said...

interview w/ sheikh sharif in uganda's new vision sticks to the talking points & simple narrative, names some names, refuses others

Al Shabaab have betrayed Islam — Somali president

[blockquote]

How many foreign fighters are there and who are they?

There is no exact number for the foreign fighters, but they are many. Some of them are from Europe, America, Asia and Africa. There are also Somali nationals who went to other countries, changed their nationality and came back.

Would you estimate them to be in their hundreds or thousands?

There are over 2,000.

Who is their commander?

The commander of the Somali terrorist fighters is called Ahmed Abdi Godane, a Somali who was trained in Afghanistan. The Somali who changed their nationality and came back are commanded by a Pakistani General called Hajir. As for al-Qaeda, Abu Yahya al-Libi (a Libyan who fought in Afghanistan in the early 1990s) was assigned to control what is going on in Somalia. Osama Bin Laden himself talked about that.

What is the role of Eritrea?

Eritrea sends money. It is a transit point for the foreign fighters to come here. Eritrean officers are in Somalia (to train al Shabaab).

Are any other countries supporting al-Shabaab?

Yes, there are other countries behind Eritrea, but we are not naming them now.

[/blockquote]

on AMISOM forces, which are largely ugandan, sh. sharif says

[blockquote]

AMISOM soldiers operate within a mandate which they know. They consult and coordinate with the government on whatever action they plan. Their discipline is good. They perform their duties actively.

[/blockquote]

from an article on monday at garowe online

7 killed in Mogadishu shelling

[blockquote]

MOGADISHU, Somalia July 27 (Garowe Online) - At least seven people were killed in the Somali capital Mogadishu on Monday after suspected insurgents attacked Somali government forces and African Union peacekeepers (AMISOM), Radio Garowe reports.

The dead were killed in an exchange of artillery fire between the warring sides, with local sources reporting that at least 15 people were wounded, mostly civilians.

The shelling was preceded by street fighting between insurgents and pro-government forces along Maka Al Mukarrama Road, an important street used by government and AMISOM forces.

Most of the killed and wounded persons died when shells hit parts of Bakara Market, the country’s largest marketplace and a stronghold of the insurgency since 2007.

[/blockquote]

so most of the dead were killed by govt-associated forces, of which AMISOM were reportedly engaged

Post a Comment