Showing newest 3 of 4 posts from November 2009. Show older posts
Showing newest 3 of 4 posts from November 2009. Show older posts

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Somalia thread for the week ending November 29

Maybe we'll see how much influence Sheikh Aweys still has w/ the business community in Mogadishu. This comes on the heels of the efforts by the TFG two weeks ago to extract "proper taxes" on goods coming through the main port, as well as Hizbul Islam's ouster from Kismayo.

Mareeg Online: Islamist rebels say small airstrip reopened
Hizbul Islam rebel group led by hardline cleric, Hassan Dahir Aweys, said they have reopened Ema’an port and Isaley airstrip in north Mogadishu on Monday.

Sheik Mohamed Moalim, a secretary information of the group said they reopened the small natural port of Elam’an and Isaley airstrip outside Mogadishu and informed business people to import and export goods in these two places.

“We call for the businessmen to import their business goods and export in Elma’an port and Isaley airport and we pledge that they will keep the security,” said Sheik Mohamed.

He said “the property of the people is robbed in Mogadishu port and airport” and called for the people to transfer their business operations into these two small places.

The move comes as Al Shabaab drove Hizbul Islam group out of the port town of Kismayo and this shows that Hizbul is trying to get an income from these two places if they convince the business people to use Isaley and Elma’an.

...

Sheik Aweys talked reports in Isaley airstrip and accused al Shabaab of being attacking bases of his group in southern Somalia.

He added that he was deeply sorry about the renewed clashes between his party and al Shabaab in Lower Jubba region.


-- -- --

The death toll from the fighting that began on Sunday rises.

Garowe Online: Heavy clashes kill 11 in Mogadishu
At least 11 people have been killed and 18 others injured in heavy fighting between Somali government forces and fighters loyal to insurgent Hizbul Islam group, Radio Garowe reports on Monday.

The clashes, which started on late Sunday and continued overnight, concentrated in the capital’s Hodan, Howlwadag and parts of Maka Al Mukarama road, where the warring sides exchanged heavy weapons including mortar shells and machine guns.

Mohammed Osman Arus, Hizbul Islam’s spokesman said that his forces carried out attacks on government and AU troops who were advancing on rebel territories, adding that they have killed several government soldiers.

“We carried out attacks on government and AMISOM troops especially Ugandans who advanced to Digfer Hospital. We forced them out of the hospital,” he told reporters in Mogadishu.

The clashes erupt[ed] after AU forces made military movement in Hodan districts especially Digfer Hospital where they briefly occupied and then vacated later in the day.


-- -- --

Garowe Online: Ethiopian and Somali officials hold secret talks
Ethiopian officials have reportedly crossed the border to neighbouring Somalia to hold secret talks with former administrators of Somalia’s southern region of Bakool in the southwestern border village of Yeed, sources reported.

Reports said Ethiopian officials from Somali region led by Barey chief Daud Abdi escorted by their troops entered the village and met with Somali officials from Bay and Bakool region who were led by Col. Adan Saransor

Sources told Garowe Online that the closed-door meetings reportedly focused on strengthening Somali troops in a bid to strengthen the forces and fight with the militants, who control much of the region including strategic town of Baidoa, the capital of Bay.
“The meeting was secret and we don’t want to reveal the outcome to the media. But the two sides discussed the military cooperation,” said a Somali official who attended the meeting.
The latest meeting raised eyebrows in the village and its environs which are currently under the Somali insurgent group Al-Shabaab.


SMC: Government officers had discussion with Ethiopian Military officers
Reliable reports coming from Hudur town the headquarters of Bakool region in north of the Somali capital Mogadishu say that top ranking officer from the Ethiopian Military have arrived at Yeed district in the region, and had discussions with the Somali government officials who are fighting with the Islamist fighters who are in control much of the region.

The top agenda of the meeting between the two sides was generally based on the security situation and how to provide military tactic to the Somali military fighting against the Al-Shababs.

During the meeting between the sides there was Ethiopian Military troops who were assigned to secure the security around were the talks were taking place. So far little is known about the discussion between the two sides, because they have not addressed the press, Somaliweyn Website has reached Abdi Fatah Gessey the regional commissioner of Bay region who was among the Somali government officials who met with the Ethiopian troops, but has avoided giving out the points discussed between sides, thought he said that all is well.

This meeting comes at a time when the Somali government troop who were ousted from their respective regions by Al-Shabab are recently carrying out series of Military exerciser at their places close the territory between Ethiopia and Somalia, and vowed to retake their regions in the soonest possible time.


-- -- --

ISN reports on the CSS Global contract, covered back in October.

Somalia Jumps on Private Security Bandwagon
That ASIMOM fires back through the very public it is mandated to protect reveals the missions’ frustrations to effectively combat against increasingly unorthodox and unexpected attacks by insurgents that, in comparison to what is needed to build a common security in Somalia, are inexpensive and relatively easy to orchestrate.

This has caused the government of Somalia to search for support from other willing parties, eventually awarding a US-based private military and security company (PMSC) a contract to “provide security consulting services and training for government forces.”

The company, Corporate Security Solutions Global (CSS Global), is a part of the larger CSS Alliance, a multi-faceted strategic and security solutions provider based in Ada, a township in western Michigan that contains less than 10,000 residents.

...

The company will do just about anything: its “Specialized HelpTeam” even provides “valet, concierge, receiving clerk, front desk, pool attendant and additional service-oriented needs.”

Concerning the side of the business on its way to Somalia, CSS Global advertises its services proudly, selling everything from personal armed security guards, convoy security, military and police training, and evacuations and extraction operations.

...

More fascinating, however, is that by securing this contract that has been awarded directly by the government of Somalia, the company now represents the first overt American presence involved with the military and security affairs of Somalia since the 1993 Battle of Mogadishu, otherwise known as the infamous Black Hawk Down situation. But this time, it is not a US state-led force on the ground, but private military and security firm.

CSS Global’s latest Somali project is interesting on several levels. According to the company, the operation is being funded by “the Arab League and other members of the international community.” If the Arab League is partly funding a private, western company that has already been compared to Blackwater to deploy to a predominately Muslim Somalia, the irony is overwhelming.

One would think this story would receive major media attention given the last time US forces were in Somalia and the Black Hawk Down debacle; however, mainstream American media has been shamefully silent on these recent developments.


One might also have thought the media would have also been all over the AU statement of September 17th regarding the "suicide attack on AMISOM Force Headquarters and a DynCorp office in Mogadishu within the vicinity of the Aden Abdulle International Airport" were it not for the apparent blackout on anything involving that company's operations in Somalia.

Continuing w/ the ISN report,

Nevertheless, while this story remains absent from any mainstream coverage, the private military and security industry is watching very closely.

...

More interesting, however, is that unlike many PMSCs that often make mainstream news coverage, CSS has been contracted by the government of Somalia directly.

Unlike the way in which companies such as Blackwater or Triple Canopy were awarded contracts by the US Department of Defense or State, CSS Global was requested by the government of Somalia. This dynamic concerns exactly to which party or parties the company will answer, how these operations will bolster or further erode the reputation of the industry in which it does business, and perhaps most importantly, what effect or byproduct its operations in Somalia will create for US-Somali relations in the future.

“I hope that today's war planners and strategists are thinking long and hard about what implications CSS Global could have on the strategy in Somalia. To say that PMCs or PSCs do not have an impact on strategy for this war is dangerously naive. To put it in [counterinsurgency] terms, CSS Global will be interacting with the local populations, like it or not, and [US strategy] has been deficient in addressing the impact the contracting community has on counter-insurgency. The silence on it in the think tank community is deafening,” Loe told ISN Security Watch.

“What is missing from this story is the lack of response from the media and from the war planners. When the story first came out, there was silence. This is a big story, because of the US history in Somalia. [The US is] going back there, and we are doing it in a roundabout way through a private military company, whether we want to or not,” [Matt Loe, an American private security contractor, former Marine and author of the online blog FeralJundi.com] said.


What a load of nonsense in those few paragraphs! The US has been heavily involved in Somalia for years now, a fact hardly disputed outside of those few who only get their news from the 'shamefull' US msm. It's hardly a secret that the current transitional government itself is the result of direct US influence, propped up by proxy forces supplied via pliant militaries from two strong allies, supported & trained by the US military and DoS contractors. Since the other members of the UN Security Council don't want the UN paying for it, the past months have seen efforts directed at coaxing pliable Arab regimes to continue feeding the money pit.

CSS Global was probably selected for the TFG.

While critics of the industry maintain that private military and security companies are used by governments in order to circumvent attention, responsibility and accountability for activities that are contracted to non-state entities, those within the industry see CSS Global’s Somali contract as an opportunity to repair the tarnished reputation of the industry. There is tremendous concern by those in the industry who are paying attention, and some remain curious about whether CSS Global has what it takes to help turn the situation in Somalia around.

“I have no doubt that al-Shabaab will do all they can to create another Blackhawk Down or Blackwater Bridge scenario to capitalize on. It would make for the ultimate in propaganda value. Or better yet, to create the environment for which a Nisour Square scenario could play out, where contractors kill civilians in a crossfire situation. Is CSS Global ready for that?” Loe said.

“I just hope that they are prepared for this kind of thing, because in essence, they are representing the US in that country again. Is CSS Global is the best company for the job, and do they have the capability and resources to make this work? Or did Somalia and the Arab League get suckered into contracting with a company that really doesn't have the experience for this kind of thing?”


Back in mid-October, when the story broke, I wrote that I'm
Expecting that CSS Global Inc, alongside DynCorp and whatever CIA presence is on the ground there, now make key targets for attacks on foreigners in Mogadishu, which plays nicely into fulfilling previously-exaggerated claims of 'terrorists' posing a real threat to U.S. citizens. Of course, if those citizens weren't meddling in control over Somalia's governance in the first place...


Let's see - only scratching the surface of some of the baggage that "representing the US in that country" that awaits the Michigan boys setting foot inside Somalia



  • US funded some vicious Somali warlords, under the guise of the Alliance for the Restoration of Peace and Counter-Terrorism, in an effort to curtail the rise of political Islam in the void of a central governing authority, which backfired and fueled the rise to power of the ICU

  • US gives Ethiopia the green light (along w/ training, logistics, etc) to invade Somalia and install Yusuf's TFG in Mogadishu -- or as one interested observer acknowledged "The thing that made encouraging the Ethiopians so easy is that Somalia didn’t really have a central government in place, which made breaching its sovereignty so easy."

  • US bypasses democratic channels for negotiations inclusive of all the actors involved in Somalia by promoting exclusive National Reconcilliation Conferences -- "funding radio messages and designing T-shirts, stickers, and banners" -- protecting Ethiopia and the (imposed) TFG and, ultimately, pressuring for the Djibouti Agreement, Yusuf's exit and a sped-up Presidential selection of Sheikh Sharif in Djibouti earlier this year, w/ many labelling him the last best hope for Somalia

  • US openly acknowledges sending money and weapons to the TFG (of which it's still not clear how it could possibly fall outside of the long-standing arms embargo) while training Somali soldiers and police forces, aiding in logistics for AMISOM (courtesy of Dyncorp, AFRICOM et al), and so on


Seems obvious to me that the party getting suckered into this situation is CSS Global. Let's just hope it doesn't lead to a quick escalation of a greater overt US presence.

-- -- --

Garowe Online is reporting that "according to unconfirmed reports, Museveni’s trip is scheduled on early December". Whenever he arrives, it'll be a hot time in the city, that's for sure.

-- -- --

Michael Weinstein's latest analysis piece focuses in on The Political Structure of the T.F.G.'s and the Puntland State's Disaccord

With a shift from economic to political emphasis, the structural imbalance is between Puntland's functioning government (although it is currently under domestic and foreign pressures) and the T.F.G.'s notional government, which is a figment of international recognition guarded by African Union tanks. Farole is a president; Sh. Sharif is a captive. Farole feels that receiving aid vouchers from the T.F.G. is not worth sacrificing self-determination; Sh. Sharif does not want to share power in a federation of regional states, which is Farole's demand. Farah recognizes this scenario in the first point of his explanation, when he says that Sh. Sharif's "mentors" were concerned that recognition of regional authorities would degrade the legitimacy of the T.F.G. in the eyes of the international community. The mentors, indeed, were correct; it was a power struggle and the T.F.G. was fighting above its weight. If the T.F.G. has only external powers to thank for its existence, Puntland has only its political organization to count on, and that is currently under stress as external pressures and threats trigger reactions against Farole's administration domestically. Protecting the status of the Puntland state trumps economic and social development.

...

The rupture in Nairobi leaves the T.F.G. weaker than ever, having lost potential support, and Puntland more isolated internationally. Farole, who had placed hope in the West and had thought that he could win a favorable deal from the T.F.G., now knows that he is on his own, which is why he has proposed by-passing the T.F.G. in the creation of a federal state that would change the present T.F.G. beyond recognition and short-circuit the donor powers' strategy of backing the T.F.G.

It is too early to tell how serious Farole is about his plan - whether it is a warning or a commitment - and whether he will have any takers for it in the southern and central regions. What it does indicate is that Farole reached the end of the rope tying him to the T.F.G. and that he has undone the knot. He has decided that the T.F.G. is not for the time being a negotiating partner and that the preservation of the state structure of Puntland is the vital interst above all others. Whether Farole is sacrificing other interests to the degree that he will subvert the vital interest through relative international isolation remains to be seen.


-- -- --

Garowe Online: Puntland respond to Donald Payne’s statement
Puntland’s Good Governance and State Minister Mohammed Farah Isse Gashan termed the [Congressman's] statement as misrepresentation that has no bases whatsoever, adding that there was no misunderstanding in the recent meeting between Puntland and the US foreign affairs representatives, which was held in Nairobi, Kenya.

“The Meeting between Puntland President and Congressman Donald Payne which took place on mid November in Nairobi has ended without misunderstanding. It is unfortunate that the press statement released from the Congressman Donald Payne’s office, which did not, had any official stamp, and was focused on threats and baseless accusations such as killings of prisoners and torture claims. We are saying that it is the work of people who are in Conflict of Interest to use office of the Congressman,” said the statement from the good governance and state minister.

The Minister said Puntland government is not a dictatorial regime as claimed by the statement from the congressman, adding that its leaders were democratically elected by the people and the state is now moving to next level whereby political parties which will allow opportunities for everyone to compete for the welfare of the state, will be formed.

Congressman Payne was the main facilitate of President Farole’s recent visit to US, which allowed the international community to directly cooperate with Puntland.

On the other hand, Minister Gashan said the government of Puntland does not need the help of anybody to protect its borders, interest, politics and people, adding that the rule of law will apply to all of its citizens and foreigners.


(what's the story behind this recent trend of so many reporters in Somalia overusing the phrase "on the other hand"? Examples for Tuesday alone include Shabelle Media, Mareeg Online, SMC, and now Garowe Online!)

-- -- --

In case anyone was wondering why other African nations have not succumbed to outside pressures to contribute bodies to AMISOM...

Garowe Online: AMISOM admits soldiers’ casualty
The African Union peacekeeping troops in Somalia have for the first time revealed that it has lost 80 of its soldiers in explosions and gun battle with Somali militants since deployed in the war-torn country two years ago, reveals AU envoy.

...

Speaking in Nairobi, the capital of Kenya on Wednesday, outgoing AU Special Envoy to Somalia Nicholas Bwakira said Uganda has lost 37 troops while Burundi has had 43 of its soldiers killed, mainly in roadside bomb explosions.


The envoy has also revealed that the peacekeepers have not received their dues for more than seven months, putting the blame solely on the donors who had only released 30 percent of the funds they pledged in Brussels early this year.


“No country would keep its forces without payment. No democracy would do that,” he said, adding that it would have ‘a very bad impact on the morale of the troops and that of the government concerned.’


VOA has more, including a link to audio of Bwakira, though I'm getting a 'file not found' error at this time.

AU Envoy Says AMISOM Troop Payments Remain In Arrears
The African Union’s Special Representative to Somalia says contributing troops from Burundi and Uganda have not been paid since May of this year.

...

“There is a sense of frustration on the part of the African Union and AMISOM. We are performing an international duty, which is the responsibility of the UN-Security Council (and) we would have expected that the international community will make financial resources available to enable us to pay the troops who are on the ground,” he said.

...

Ambassador Bwakira said morale is noticeably low among AMISOM and Somali government troops.

...

Of the more than $295 million pledged at the Brussels conference in April, the Somali government has realized only three million dollars. Two million dollars came from the United States, and another million from the Arab League.


"Since May of this year" would mean that they were paid in May but not June, correct? June through November is six months.

But the Daily Monitor, which one would expect to get the numbers right wrt the Ugandan forces, essentially rearranges the VOA report, adding

With each soldier on duty in Mogadishu budgeted to earn an average $550 (about Shs1 million) each month, the arrears due to the 3,000 UPDF soldiers alone over the months, the seventh being the ending November, thus add to some $11.6 million (Shs21.6 billion).


Here, "the seventh being the [month] ending [in] November" then suggests that May was the first month of arrears, not the last month to receive payment, which makes Bwakira's statement confusing.

Adding to that, throw in this report from the Daily Nation on Thursday

African Union names new representative in Mogadishu
The African Union has a new representative in Somalia. He is Mr Boubacar Gaoussou Diarra from the West African state of Mali.

Mr Diarra replaces Mr Nicolas Bwakira who has held the post for two years.

Addressing a press conference in Nairobi, Mr Bwakira said African Union troops in Somalia have not been paid for eight months.


jeez.. is there a transcript somewhere?

On the other point of the TFG only getting three million from the Brussels pledges, most of that money was earmarked for the AU and not the TFG, anyway. Still, in the same way that other Africa leaders are smart enough to understand that there is no peace to keep in Mogadishu, foreign leaders recognize that the United States' "best hope" in Mogadishu isn't really a govt either.

Which makes this Reuters story all the more bizarre

Somalia to tackle piracy, terrorism in 2010 budget
Somalia's Western-backed government plans a big increase in spending next year chiefly funded by foreign donors, with a large chunk going on battling piracy and hardline rebels, a minister told Reuters on Friday.

...

International Cooperation Minister Abdirahman Abdishakur Warsame said that an increase in donor funds would help the government to extend its influence across the country, which Western security experts say has become a safe haven for militants who use it to plot attacks in the region and beyond.

"I hope our partners will support the new budget because our main concern is security, especially tackling terrorism and piracy which are two huge problems," he said in an interview.

"I believe that if we obtain the necessary financial backing to pay our forces, we can defeat the pirates. It is a simple network of criminals, but we lack the capacity and finances to address this problem."

The government planned to spend $108 million in 2010, 74 percent of which it hopes will be provided by donors, Abdishakur said. This represented a big jump from the $39.6 million it expects to have spent in 2009, and about 40 percent of next year's funds would be allocated to the security services.


-- -- --

On the topic of Uganda,

The Observer: Museveni, Bahati, named in US ‘cult’
President Museveni, Ethics Minister Nsaba Buturo and MP David Bahati have been linked to a shadowy religious fundamentalist group in the United States known as the ‘The Family’.

...

According to journalist, academic and author Jeff Sharlett, who has spent years researching on The Family, its core agenda includes fighting homosexuality and abortion, promoting free-market economics and dictatorship, an idea they once termed “totalitarianism for Christ”.

It recruits people in positions of power and influence to promote its agenda and, according to Sharlett, the group has had its sights on Uganda for over 20 years.

...

In an extensive interview with National Public Radio (NPR), a privately and publicly funded non-profit radio network in the United States, Jeff Sharlett said that The Family identified President Museveni as their “key man in Africa” in 1986.

Individuals working for both the US government and The Family, he said, undertook trips to Uganda “to reach out to Museveni to make sure that he came into the American sphere of influence [and] that Uganda, in effect, becomes our proxy in the region”.

“They wanted to steer him away from neutrality or leftist sympathies and bring him into conservative American alliances, and they were able to do so. They’ve since promoted Uganda as this bright spot - as I say, as this bright spot for African democracy, despite the fact that under their tutelage, Museveni has slowly shifted away from any even veneer of democracy: imprisoning journalists, tampering with elections, supporting - strongly supporting this Anti-Homosexuality Act of 2009,” he said.

Describing Museveni as a “core” member of the group, Jeff Sharlett alleged that President Museveni visits, spends time and “sits down for counsel” with Doug Coe, the leader of The Family, at the group’s headquarters at a place called The Cedars in Arlington, Virginia.

...

Senator Tom Coburn, who also sits on the Senate Arms Forces Committee, is quoted to have said he has been on a mission to Uganda to “promote the political philosophy of Jesus as taught to him by Doug Coe.”

The group, Jeff Sharlett told NPR, creates “an invisible believing group of God-led politicians who get together and talk with one another about what God wants them to do in their leadership capacity. And that’s the nature of their relationship with Museveni.”

The Family, according to Sharlett, helped the Museveni family and other top politicians to start the annual National Prayer Breakfast in Uganda, to which it sends representatives, as a parallel to the United States National Prayer Breakfast the group has been running since 1935.

...

Jeff Sharlett says he has established in recent investigations that the group has been channeling money to Uganda to promote its activities, including the anti-gay Bill.

Following paper trails, he discovered that the money was channeled through an “African leadership academy” called Cornerstone which runs a Youth Corps programme described as an “invisible family binding together world leaders” and an organisation called the “African Youth Leadership Forum” associated with MP David Bahati.

“The Family has poured millions of dollars working through a very convoluted chain of linkages passing the money over to Uganda,” he said. According to Jeff Sharlett, in Uganda, Museveni, Buturo and Bahati are not merely under the influence of The Family but they are, in effect, The Family.

The Observer tried to get MP Bahati to shed some light on these claims but he could not be reached on all known telephone numbers. Neither could we speak to Ethics and Integrity Minister, James Nsaba Buturo, as he did not answer his phone.

Presidential Press Secretary, Tamale Mirundi, said he was neither aware of an organisation called The Family nor of any relationship between it and President Museveni. But should such ties exist, Mirundi said, he would not be surprised.


Here's a link to the full transcript of NPR's Sharlett interview:

The Secret Political Reach Of 'The Family'

One excerpt from that interview by Fresh Air's Terry Gross

GROSS: How did The Family create its relationship with Museveni?

Mr. SHARLET: In 1986, a former Ford official name Bob Hunter went over on trips at the behest of the U.S. government, but also on behalf of The Family, to which - for which both of which he filed reports that are now in The Family's archives. And his goal was to reach out to Museveni and make sure that he came into the American sphere of influence, that Uganda, in effect, becomes our proxy in the region and that relationship only deepened.

In fact, in late 1990s, Hunter - again, working for The Family - went over and teamed up with Museveni to create the Uganda National Prayer Breakfast as a parallel to the United States National Prayer Breakfast and to which The Family every year sends representatives, usually congressmen.

GROSS: What's the relationship of Museveni and The Family now?

Mr. SHARLET: It's a very close relationship. He is the key man. Now...

GROSS: So what does that mean? What influence does The Family have on him?

Mr. SHARLET: It means that they have a deep relationship of what they'll call spiritual counsel, but you're going to talk about moral issues. You're going to talk about political issues. Your relationships are going to be organized through these associates. So Museveni can go to Senator Brownback and seek military aid. Inhofe, as he describes, Inhofe says that he cares about Africa more than any other senator.

And that may be true. He's certainly traveled there extensively. He says he likes to accuse the State Department of ignoring Africa so he becomes our point man with guys like Museveni and Uganda, this nation he says he's adopted. As we give foreign aid to Uganda, these are the people who are in a position to steer that money. And as Museveni comes over, and as he does and spends time at The Family's headquarters in Arlington, Virginia, a place called The Cedars, and sits down for counsel with Doug Coe, that's where those relationships occur.

It's never going to be the hard sell, where they're going to, you know, twist Museveni's arm behind his back and say do this. As The Family themselves describes it, you create a prayer cell, or what they call - and this again, this is their language from their documents - an invisible believing group of God-led politicians who get together and talk with one another about what God wants them to do in their leadership capacity. And that's the nature of their relationship with Museveni.


-- -- --

Regarding that Garowe Online I questioned last week which quoted anon sources claiming Aweys was clandestinely joining Harakat al-Shabaab Mujihideen

Mareeg Online: Sheikh Aweys expresses his anger against al Shabaab
The aging, hardline cleric, Sheikh Hassan Dahir Aweys, who leads Hizbul Islam rebel group showed his anger against al Shabaab actions for the first time on Friday.

Addressing to hundreds of people in Elasha Biyaha settlement during the festival of Eidul Ad’ha Sheikh Aweys called for al Shabaab to stop calling his group apostates and added that the fighting between the two groups in Lower Jubba region was not a religious one.

...

“We have to abstain from shedding blood and aggressions against each other,” said Sheik Aweys.

He added that negations between the two groups stopped and the fighting was continuing, but he hoped that the negations will start again.

Sheikh Aweys says his group was not attacking al Shabaab, and will stop the fighting when the other group stops.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Somalia thread for the week ending November 22

Seems to be a lot of "firsts" this week in Somalia...

Garowe Online: Ahlu-Sunnah Wal-Jama slams Somali President’s remarks
Somalia’s Ahlu Sunnah Wal-Jama has condemned remarks made by Somali president Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed, terming it as insult to the group.

In an interview with BBC Somali Service, President Ahmed describe the group as any another armed militia fighting in his war-torn country.

Sheikh Omar Sheikh Mohammed Farah, Ahlu-Sunnah’s chairman slammed the remarks as an insult to his group.

“President Sheikh Sharif has openly ignored our existence, describing us as guerrillas just like Al-Shabaab and Hizbul Islam,” he said in a press conference.

Sheikh Farah called on the president to apologize within 48-hours or else his group will take unspecified action against the Somali government.

In the interview, President Sharif stated that there are on-going talks with pro-government group in joining his administration, a statement which the group’s leader rejected and termed it as lies.

The group’s leader said they will formally lodged their complains and agreement with TFG to the parliament, urging parliamentarians to respond about the president’s remarks.

It is the first time the group, which declared its support to the fragile UN-backed transition government, to strongly criticize the government.


SMC: Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama criticises President Shariff’s speech
The emotion of the faction which is a close allay of the current government of Somali was aroused when President Shariff has said that the faction of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama is a tribal based faction.

The administration of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama has loud and clear said that the President has flagrantly committed a crime against them so he should immediately repent and give a apologise through the media, or else the faction will suspend their support to his government.

...

“The president of Somalia has committed peccadillo against us and we are asking him to immediately give apologize through the media or else his statement will have awful impact in the relation between the current government led by him and the faction of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama” said Sheikh Omar Sheikh Mohammed Farah the chairman of the administration sector of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama in a press conference.

...

On the other hand Dahir Abdul Kadir a lawmaker in the Somali government, has sent a message apologise to the entire members of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama regarding about the offence which they said the President of Somalia has committed against their faction.

“The entire of the Somali lawmakers deeply regret the differences which has emerged between them and Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama, in fact we know that Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama always says that it is part of the Somali transitional federal government, and we are sending our apologise to the faction of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama” said Dahir Abdul Kadir the lawmaker.

It is not yet known how this statement from the Somali parliamentarian will convince the faction of Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama.


Garowe Online: Somali lawmakers call on president to resign
Some lawmakers have called on the embattled President Sheikh Sharif Sheikh Ahmed to resign over incompetence and making several foreign trips since his election.

The MPs who met in Mogadishu, accused the president of failing to stabilize the war-torn country, urging him to pave the way for the election of a new leader who can serve his people better.

“The president has went loggerheads with Puntland, the only state that is supporting his government and Ahlu-Sunnah group which backs him,” said Dahir Abdikadir Irro, one of Somali MPs.

...

“If Sheikh Sharif fails to fulfil his duties, we think its best for him to step aside before parliament revokes his position,” said the lawmakers.

...

It is first time that Somali lawmakers have called on the embattled president to hand over the leadership.


Also,

Shabelle Media: Ahlu sunna clerics order people in central Somalia not to watch films
the Islamic clerics of Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a have ordered the people in Abudwaq district in central Somalia not to watch films, witnesses told Shabelle radio on Wednesday.

The clerics said publicly that they totally banned watching films through the district saying that the films could lead the people in wrong and evil deeds asserting that all men and the women will be taken a right step if they did not abide by the Islamic clerics’ order in Abudwaq district in central Somalia.

The clerics also refused drivers to drive the trucks with very high speed through the district while traveling.

It is the first time the Islamist clerics of Ahlu Sunna Waljama’a clerics issue like this orders against the people in the town to watch movie and also to drive very high speed thought the town which meant the people to follow the right way that Allah has ordered his slaves to follow.


But, just when new things start popping, there's always old reliable Ould Abdallah, still clinging to the same ole' tired attempts to control information and shape perceptions...

Inner City Press: UN's Somalia Envoy Blames Web Sites for Aid Cut Off and Child Soldier Reports
The UN's top envoy to Somalia Ahmedou Ould Abdallah was asked Wednesday by the Press about the reported suspension of U.S. aid due to diversion to the Al Shabaab rebels, and the recruitment of Somalia refugees in Kenya to come back to fight Al Shabaab. He dodged both questions by referring to the ills of online media and web sites.

When Inner City Press asked about the recruitment of fighters including child soldiers in refugee camps in Kenya, Ould Abdallah replied that Somalis have "three hundred web sites... People write and print what they want." Video here, from Minute 0:54. But the sites reporting this include the UN's own ReliefWeb.int, here.

Likewise, when Inner City Press asked about reports -- by both the Wall Street Journal and New York Times -- of the suspension or delay of U.S. aid due to diversion of World Food Program funds to Al Shabaab, Ould Abdallah said "they campaign through web sites [that] they don't don't like help" from the U.S. or WFP. He added that it is difficult to prevent diversion. ...

Then Ould Abdullah turned his comments on Inner City Press itself, saying "you are very specific. You ask only controversial or difficult issues." ... Given that the alternative is to ask bland or easy question, "that's journalism," Inner City Press replied. "It is not journalism," Ould Abdallah said.

Ould Abdallah ended his 11 minute stakeout by asking an intern, "Who are you with?" When told the name of the cable television network, Ould Abdallah directed the intern to ask a question, since "he [Inner City Press] monopolize." ...

Since Ould Abdallah's spokesperson Susanna Price has refused to answer e-mailed questions about who paid for UN-sponsored conferences and the Transitional Federal Goverment's wages and security, and about Ould Abdullah's role in a Norwegian funded, Kenyan drafts Law of the Sea filing subsquently voted down by Somalia's parliament, to ask Ould Abdallah four questions after none for many month hardly seems a monopoly.

Ould Abdallah previously called for a moratorium on the reporting of the killing of civilians by AMISOM peacekeepers in Somalia, saying that these reports only led to more strife. When Human Rights Watch and others called for him to retract the censorship call or resign, he did neither.

Secretariat sources say Ould Abdallah was asked to apologize, but that he refused. "He called the UN's bluff," said a source. "They feel that they need him." This is what the UN has come to.


-- -- --

From the November 18th Ecoterra International SMCM

SPANISH BROKE DEAL SAY PIRATES
Several local observers from the pirate lairs of Harardheere and Ceel Hur give an account different to the media spin below.

They all agree in two points:

A) The helicopter from the warship went after the group, which had brought the 3 Spanish hostages from the coast onto the fishing vessel Alakrana, while they returned to the coast. But the chopper only did reach them when they were already close to the beach and therefore only could manage to shoot up the boat, while the Somalis escaped. Only one of them was slightly wounded in the attack.

Thereafter the helicopter gunship went after a car, which was leaving the village of Ceel Hur, but the occupants heard the chopper coming and abandoned the car in the middle of the track, diving into the bush. While the car was severely hit by gunfire from the helicopter, no person was killed or wounded.

B) The captors of FV ALAKRANA actually had an argument already before the release of the vessel concerning the release of the 3 Spaniards held as hostages for the return of two Somalis arrested in Spain.

In the first instance the group, which argued that the Spanish had promised more money if all crew members are released and that the two Somalis would be returned to them based on the word of honor given by the Spanish Ambassador to Kenya, won the upper hand and no real fight ensued while they managed to bring the 3 Spanish Sailors back to the vessel. But when upon return the arrangement of a peaceful release was broken by the attack of the Spanish helicopter and also a group of those, who had opposed the plan and wanted to keep the Spaniards as safety, were attacked while driving away in their car, these men felt that they had been betrayed by the return party, which caused a brief exchange of angry gunfire between the two groups causing four men to be wounded.

At no time there was a fight over the agreed ransom money both sides stated, but those who had not wanted to release the 3 spanish sailors kept on land, thought that the other group had received extra cash for the return of the three and wanted their share of that. Only when they realized that actually also the return party had been attacked by the helicopter, both sides understood that broken agreement was targeting all.

The group of sea-shifta holding the Alakrana had vowed earlier that if the Spanish Ambassador would brake his word they would keep the British couple taken hostage from their yacht as pawn.

Spanish Prosecutor Jesus Alonso therefore might not only want to have a look into the dealings of the owner of the vessel, the middlemen and the lawyers but also under the doormats and the carpets of the Spanish government, the embassy and the Spanish navy, if true justice shall prevail.

One sad record does the FV ALAKRANA hold already - it's the highest sum ever paid worldwide for the release of a fishing vessel.


Further on in issue 290, they note that

The Spaniards made so many mistakes in this case, that regional analysts as well as professional K&R (kidnapping & ransom) negotiators working on anti-piracy believe the Alakrana case will have serious negative implications for the future as well as the present 14 hostage cases - all certainly negative for the hostages and all leading to a further escalation, they stated. The Spanish proposal to blockade three piracy ports with Kanonenbootpolitik would just be the joke of the year along the 3,330 km long coastlines of Somalia.


and on the stories of the Maersk Alabama again being the target of unsuccessful hijackers on Wednesday, they add

This vessel is regularly working under a special contract with the US Department of Defence. The company refused to rename the vessel and maybe the Somali sea-shifta know better what is in the containers.


and then point out this AP story

US calls for intensified efforts to combat piracy and warns against paying ransom
The United States of America is calling for intensified efforts to combat piracy and warning against paying ransom.
U.S. deputy ambassador Rosemary DiCarlo expressed concern that ransom payments have contributed to the recent increase in piracy.
She said the United States is encouraging all countries to adopt a policy of “no concessions” when dealing with pirates.
DiCarlo spoke at an open meeting of the U.N. Security Council Wednesday on the fight against piracy.

The long scheduled meeting coincided with Wednesday’s second attack by Somali pirates in seven months against the U.S.-flagged ship the Maersk Alabama, which was thwarted by private guards onboard, and payment of a $3.3 million ransom to Somali pirates on Tuesday to free a Spanish trawler and its 36 crew members.

[N.B.: In the corridors people were asking each other how much the Somali pirates actually were paid for this timely stunt.]


-- -- --

Somaliland Press: Some 350 Troops Complete Training in Djibouti
Djibouti prime Minister Dileita Mohamed Dileita today attended the ceremony to mark the end of training of some 350 Somali soldiers by France.

The charge d’affaires at the Somali embassy in Djibouti, Mr Abourhaman Mohamed Hirabe, the French ambassador, Mr Dominique Decherf, the chief of staff of French forces stationed in Djibouti (FFDJ), Brig Gen Thierry Caspar-Fille-Lambie, as well as several top Djibouti and French military officers also attended the ceremony which took place at Myriam Camp some 70 kilometres from the capital.

Following in the example of the first group of 154 elements of the Somali security forces trained by France a few months ago, the second contingent of 350 men also received training that lasted about six weeks.

The training overseen by the 5th RIAOM [French Overseas Interarmy Regiment] was aimed at instilling in the Somali soldiers the basics of international law of war and to create the beginnings of a group spirit.

It is worth noting that the French government had broached with the European Union a suggestion of training 3,000 additional Somali security forces, a plan which will goes in hand with the training of national coast guards in the area. Financed by Japan and the EU, a centre based in Djibouti with the support of Kenya, Oman, Tanzania, but also the provinces of Somaliland and Puntland will open in January 2010.

France’s support for the transitional government and more precisely its participation in the putting together of a Somali national security force comes in the framework of UN Resolution 1872, France’s ambassador to Djibouti explained, adding that he was convinced that the process launched by his country opens a new path to the reconstruction process and the pacification of Somalia.


-- -- --

AP on Monday ran a long story on the recruitment of ethnic Somalis in Kenya, Kenyans recruited to fight in Somalia, which borrowed alot from the HRW report, but also reported the following

Thousands of people, including children, are being secretly recruited and trained inside Kenya to battle Islamic insurgents in neighboring Somalia, according to deserters, local officials, families of recruits and diplomats. Most recruits are Somalis living in crowded refugee camps and Kenyan nationals who are ethnic Somalis living nearby.

Spokesmen from the Kenyan government, police and military, as well as the Somali chief of military staff, have denied that the government is recruiting fighters within Kenya. But interviews showed that recruiting has been taking place for months and that different government agencies and military resources — including vehicles with government license plates — have been involved.

...

Eight diplomats, citing internal reports and other sources, told The Associated Press that the recruits are being trained for a planned offensive on behalf of Somalia's weak, U.N.-backed government to wrest control of parts of southern Somalia from the insurgents. The diplomats spoke on condition of anonymity to prevent damaging relations with Kenya over the sensitive subject. Two of the diplomats said the offensive is planned for the end of Somalia's rainy season around the end of the year.

...

About two months ago, recruiters started openly operating in Kenyan towns and in nearby huts and tents of the refugee camps, according to more than 20 interviews with recruits, their families and religious, municipal and civil society leaders. Some recruiters even worked from a hotel fronting a heavily fortified U.N. compound in the northern town of Dadaab, home to three overcrowded camps of about 275,000 refugees, most from Somalia.

Baijo Mohamed, chairman of a youth group in Dadaab's Ifo camp, said he had been approached by two Somali generals to help recruit fighters but refused because he did not want to see his friends die in a war they are not responsible for.

More than a dozen deserters said they were promised positions in the Kenyan or Somali armies or jobs with U.N. security by men acting as recruiters. Some said they were told they would patrol the Kenya-Somalia border. But upon arrival at the training camp, they were told they were going to Somalia's capital, Mogadishu, or Kismayo, a key southern city under Islamist control.

...

Kenyan Defense Ministry spokesman Bogita Ongeri denied a secret militia is being formed or that the military was involved in any recruitment or training. ... adding that the only training taking place is Kenyan police training Somali police.

"The military is not involved at all in any training of any Somali forces," he said. "This is propaganda being disseminated by some militia groups in Somalia."

Police spokesman Eric Kiraithe said he is not aware of any such police training by Kenya. Alejandro Bendana, the manager for the U.N. program training Somali police, also said he knew of no such U.N.-related training in Kenya. The main training area for police recruits is in the northern Somali region of Puntland, Bendana said. [Is that correct?]

Ismail Garat, the deputy mayor of the northern town of Garissa, about 60 miles (100 kilometers) from Dadaab, said he has received many complaints from constituents about the recruitment for the secret militia.

"They recruited retired Kenyan army officers first," Garat said. "Then they came back and began to take the youth."

Garat estimated at least 300 young men disappeared from the town into the militia. Garat's brother was among those approached and the deputy mayor had to persuade him to return.

Hussein Mahad, the secretary of the Council of Imams and Preachers for the town, said all 100 of the imams in his group have reported complaints about the recruitment drive. He said he knew of a woman whose husband, a retired Kenyan soldier, had joined early in the process and whose son was taken later.

Garat said trucks from the Kenya National Youth Service with government license plates took away the recruits from Garissa at night. Witnesses told him military escorts were sometimes present. Most of the recruits from Dadaab said they were also transported on trucks with government plates.

The deserters all said they were taken to Manyani, a training center for the Kenya Wildlife Service outside the port of Mombasa. They said their cell phones were confiscated upon arrival and Kenyan citizens had to surrender their identity cards.

...

Both Somali and Kenyan military officials were involved in the training, the recruits said, adding that they recognized Kenya's green military uniform and beret on some trainers while others wore plain clothes.

Salad Dahir, a tall, thin man in a tattered blue shirt, said he had traveled to the training site in the crowded, sweltering truck about a month ago. He said the Kenyan military did the training — push-ups and other calisthenics.

"Kenya military were there wearing uniforms," added Hassan.

...

Several recruits said they know of dozens of minors in the militia, and one spoke of a boy as young as 11.

"The recruiters said, 'Even if you're 15, you're still old enough to handle a gun,'" said 16-year-old Ahmed Omar, one of four minors who deserted.

Northern Kenya legislator Adan Keynan, chairman of Kenya's Defense and Foreign Relations parliamentary committee, said parliament has opened an investigation into the recruitment allegations. He declined to comment on the inquiry but said several politicians have complained of the recruiting drive.

Gen. Yusuf Ahmed Dhumal, chief of staff of Somalia's military, denied recruitment is taking place in Kenya. He said Kenya is training 1,500 Somalis recruited in Somalia as soldiers to support the Somali government. Training is also taking place in Ethiopia and Djibouti with U.S. support, he said.


-- -- --

SMC: The State Minister of Defence aplogises [to] Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama
Honorable Sheikh Yussuf Mohammed Siyad best known as Inda’ade has sent a message of apologise on behalf of the Somali President his Excellency President Sheikh.

...

“It would something of respect that if the faction of Ahlu-sunnah thinks that the Somali government has violated them, they should have not said their feelings through the media, but instead contact the government, so that we would have sorted out together all the weak points, so now on behalf of the Somali Transitional Federal Government I am sending apologise to our brothers Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama” said Sheikh Yussuf Mohammed Siyad the Somalia State Minister for defence in a press conference.

On the other hand the state Minister has lashed with words a Somali legislator who had talked to the press saying that the President has sinned against Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama.

“The legislator is neither the President of nation whom Ahlu-Sunnah Waljama has committed crime against them nor the Speaker of the House and in very country there is constitution tio guide the country, it is something disgracing for an MP just to reach at the Microphone of the Press and say anything that comes a cross his mind” added the state Minister.



Shabelle Media adds
“On behalf of the voice of the transitional Federal Government president Sharif Sheik Ahmed, we are apologizing for the Islamic clerics of Ahlu sunna Waljama’a for statement that the Somali president suggested recently. Really are apologizing our brothers Ahlu sunna Waljama’a who infuriated the president’s speech and demanded to be responded by the officials of the government as soon as possible,” said Sheik Yusuf Mohamed.


-- -- --

Shabelle Media: Two government soldiers killed, more wounded in fire exchange in Mogadishu
at least two government soldiers have been killed and more than five others have been wounded in a fire exchange between the transitional government troops in the Somali capital Mogadishu, witnesses told Shabelle radio on Thursday.

Sources close to the TFG said that the fighting started at the front gate of the transitional government Prime Minister Omar Abdirashid Ali Sharma’arke in Mogadishu as the transitional cabinet concluded their meeting at the PM’s office in the capital.

Locals said that the fighting was between the security guards of two ministers who were member of the transitional ministers who were taking part in the meeting as they dispute and misunderstood adding that two soldiers died while more others wounded during the clash of both sides which reportedly said that the AMISOM troops who were in the Somali PM’s office in Mogadishu mediated them and achieved to halt their gun battle.

We had contacted with some the government officials to know more on the reason. But declined to give further details about the clash of the government soldiers and It is unclear the real aim that both soldiers fought in the capital so far.


-- -- --

Mareeg Online: Ethiopian troops deployed near Somali border
More Ethiopian troops have been deployed near the Somali border in Gedo region in western Somalia, witnesses and officials said on Thursday.

Reports from the region say Somali soldiers are accompanying the Ethiopian forces who were deployed near the border.

Residents say the Ethiopian troops made military movement and operations in Sufka area in the border between the two countries.

It is not known the reason behind the movement of the Ethiopian troops, but Islamist rebels control towns near the Ethiopian border with Somalia.

Sheikh Salman, an Islamist official from Hizbul Islam rebel group in the region says they had information about the Ethiopian troops and added that the Ethiopian soldiers were aiding “Somali militias”.

“We know that the Ethiopian soldiers are in Sufka settlement and are escorting Somali militias to attack the regions controlled by the Mujahideen,” said Sheik Salman.

A Somali government official, who requested not to be named, said they were planning attacks against the rebels to reclaim region under the control of the Islamist rebels.

-- -- --

Drones?

Mareeg Online: Planes flying low level seen in Kismayo
Planes flying with low level have been seen in the port town of Kismayo 500 km south of the Somali capital Mogadishu overnight, witnesses said on Friday.

Residents say they could hear load sound coming from the planes which were repeatedly flying over the city. It is not known the motive behind the planes and which country they belonged to.

Residents expressed concern about the planes which were flying over the city.


-- -- --

A press release issued Friday by Congressman Donald Payne, chair of the House Subcommittee on Africa and Global Health,
In late October, the Puntland government arrested five men of Ogadeni origin. These men came to Puntland using Somali travel documents provided by Somali authorities in Yemen.

Puntland and Ethiopian security personnel, invited by Puntland authorities, interrogated the prisoners. One of the prisoners, Abdi Mohamed Hassan also known as “Abdi Teerso” was handed over to Ethiopian security. Another prisoner died while in custody. An elderly man from Puntland was arrested by Puntland authorities after he publicly criticized the government.

This is not the first time Puntland authorities have harassed, tortured, killed, and handed over men of Ogadeni origin to Ethiopian security. Over a year ago, two senior members of the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) were handed over to Ethiopian security by a Puntland minister. They came, with the permission of Puntland authorities, to discuss the murder of an elder.

In June 2009, I invited President Abdirahman Mohamed Mohamud (Farole) of Puntland to testify before my Subcommittee on Somalia. After the hearing, I discussed a number of issues with him, including the targeting and the handing over of Ogadenis to Ethiopian authorities. I was assured then that this would not happen again and that the government would reach out to this community.

In an effort to resolve the recent detention of the five men, I called the President of Puntland to discuss my concerns and strongly urged him to release them without delay. I even proposed that the men be sent to another country where they will be safe. A week passed and nothing happened.

In mid-November, I met again with the President of Puntland and his Interior Minister in Kenya to urge them to release the three men still in detention in Puntland. Again, he pledged to find ways to pardon the prisoners. In fact, Puntland authorities are now threatening non-Puntland Somalis to leave some areas within 48 hours.

I strongly condemn this abusive and dictatorial behavior and demand the immediate release of the prisoners. I also call for those responsible for the killing of the prisoner and intimidation of Ogadenis to be held accountable, including senior officials who authorized these measures. Failure to act quickly on this matter will have serious consequences.


Interesting that there's no mention by Payne of the role of Puntland's Intelligence Service, the PIS...

From a March 30th report at Garowe Online:

[President Farole] expressed regret at the loss of life following an incident in the port city of Bossaso, where Puntland Intelligence Service (PIS) soldiers arrested a local cleric last week, sparking riots.

"Puntland security is the responsibility of security forces paid by the Puntland government. There are other security agencies, who are paid from elsewhere," President Farole added ambiguously.

The PIS has secretive ties to Western intelligence agencies, especially the American CIA, with widespread reports indicating that PIS soldiers are paid, trained and equipped by the CIA.


Even the major wire service AFP reported on April 29th of this year that

The Puntland intelligence service (PIS) was established nearly a decade ago and has been at the centre of heated debate since Abdirahman Mohamed Farole was elected as president of the region in January.

Although officially part of the Puntland interior ministry, the PIS is believed to be largely funded by Western agencies and has often operated outside of the Puntland administration's authority.


Payne carefully avoids mentioning PIS' role even in the 2008 extradition, which was also covered by Garowe Online on April 25, 2008

Abdinur Mohamed Soyan and Dhire Oof, both members of the ONLF Central Committee, were arrested by Puntland Intelligence Service (PIS) agents on April 22 at a hotel in Garowe, the capital city of Puntland.

...

An independent inquiry by Garowe Online discovered that Mr. Soyan’s relative was wounded earlier this month by PIS agents, who raided his home and arrested him for yet-unspecified reasons.

...

Traditional elders in Bossaso were successful in helping release Mr. Soyan’s wounded relative from jail briefly, but the sources said PIS agents raided his home for a second time and placed him back in jail.

It was learned that Mr. Soyan’s wounded relative later died in incarceration from gunshot wounds sustained during the first PIS raid, according to well-placed sources who did not wish to be named in print.

...

According to a Web site statement from the ONLF, both officials arrested by Puntland regional authorities were “unarmed political figures and posed no threat to the security of Puntland.”

The ONLF online statement alleged that the two officials – Mr. Soyan and Mr. Oof – were interrogated by PIS agents in Garowe before being transported in the personal car of Puntland Finance Minister Mohamed “Gaagaab” Ali to the Ethiopian border, where Ethiopian intelligence officers awaited.


Not wanting to be misinterpreted as to suggest laying everything at the feet of "Western intelligence agencies, especially the American CIA", Ethiopia, of course, holds a lot of influence in Puntland. As the Ogaden Human Rights committee pointed out at the time of the 2008 extraditions,

These regional entities such as Puntland and Somaliland are not independent from Ethiopian interference.

Ethiopia established an intelligence-gathering bureau called “Ethiopian Interest Protection Office” to pursue members of its opposition through its numerous agents in Hargeisa and Garowe who have been given free license to detain, rape, torture and kill any Somali from the Ogaden suspected of being an ONLF supporter.

Due to the magnitude and scale of the oppression and violations of the basic human rights in the Ogaden, a large number of Somalis from the Ogaden region flee from their homeland to neighbouring countries, including Puntland, seeking asylum, shelter and safety.

Refugees from the Ogaden who escape from the Ethiopian government’s unceasing infringement on their basic human rights are being persecuted in Puntland as well as Somaliland and TFG areas, where they are constantly imprisoned, tortured and then handed over to the Ethiopian government in exchange for ammunition, materials or simply to prove loyalty, cooperation and friendship to Ethiopia.


-- -- --

Shabelle Media: AMISOM troops make new military base in Mogadishu
the African Union troops (AMISOM) have made new military base in Digfer hospital in Mogadishu, just as they blockaded the movement of the traffic of Mekka Al-murakama street in the capital on Sunday morning.

More troops of the AU with armed vehicles could be seen in forming new base in the hospital, a former base of the transitional government troops in south of Mogadishu.

Residents in the areas of the hospital expressed concern about the deployment of the AU forces who were also making military movement there adding that they had had the fears of fighting that starts in Hodan district in Banadir region.

...

More troops with battlewagons could also be seen around Makka Al-mukaram Street; a key road that connects between the presidential palace and Km4, a base for the Ugandan troops in Mogadishu and making military movement on the street which they also blockaded its movement from the use of the traffic in Mogadishu.

Resident in Mogadishu expressed fears as they saw the tanks of the AMISOM troops in more areas like Makka Al-mukarama, Wadnaha, Sayidka and Taribunka, all the main streets of south and central of the Somali capital Mogadishu.


Somaliweyn Media Center reported that
Digfer hospital ... once used to be largest hospital in Somali.

The troops have taken position after a company of the Somali national police were overnight evacuated from that very base which the AU troops have stationed themselves on Sunday.


Later Sunday,

Shabelle Media: Heavy fighting kills two, wounds 5 others in Mogadishu
at least two people have killed and 5 others wounded after heavy fighting between the Islamist fighters and the transitional government troops backing by AMISOM broke out in parts of the Somali capital Mogadishu, witnesses and officials told Shabelle radio on Sunday.

Reports say that fighting started around 5:00 pm local time on Sunday afternoon in parts of Hadan and Hawl-wadag districts and also parts of Makke Al-mukarama street in the capital.

...

Locals said that the clashes also spread further and bitterly continued at Dabka intersection, a key position for the transitional government troops and Shaqalaha, another military base for the Burundian troops in the long street of Makka Al-mukarama which connects between the presidential palace and Km4, an important base for the Ugandan troops.

At least two people where reportedly killed and 5 others wounded as a mortar shell landed into parts of Barmudo neighborhoodin Hodan district according to a resident who gave an interview to Shabelle radio to night.

The real casualties of the fighting is unclear so far as there are more of the emergency traffic vehicles of Life Line Africa those are currently traveling through the areas of the fighting as the fighting is yet continuing.

Mohamed Osman Arus, a spokesman of the Islamic organization of Hisbul Islam for the operations confirmed to Shabelle radio that the fighting started as they attacked the bases of the AMISOM troops in Mogadishu.


Garowe Online fine-tunes the picture a bit more

Mohammed Osman Arus, Hizbul Islam’s spokesman said that his forces carried out attacks on government and AU troops who were advancing on rebel territories.

The clashes erupt after AU forces made military movement in Hodan districts especially Digfer Hospital where they briefly occupied and then vacated later in the day.


This Mareeg Online article is the only source I can find at the moment announcing a visit from Museveni to Mogadishu, and it does so in such an ambiguous way that it's suggestive of it having been the cause of the AMISOM manuevers.

Ugandan President to visit Mogadishu
Ugandan President, Yoweri Museveni, is to visit the Somalia capital Mogadishu, where thousands of Ugandan troops are based as a part of the African Union Troops in Somalia, reports said on Sunday.

The reports say President Museveni will visit the Ugandan troops in the capital and also will meet his Somalia counterpart Sheik Sharif Ahmed.

The African Union troops were deployed in Maka Mukarrma road that connects the airport and the presidential palace.

The African Union Troops have also made operations in the road to pave the way for the arrival of the president.

It was this morning when the AU troops made new military base in former Digfeer Hospital in Mogadishu.


-- -- --

Not sure what to make of this story right now - it sounds similar to previous propaganda efforts and, even if Hizbul Islam is truly on the verge of collapsing altogether, it's not clear what gain would be made.

Garowe Online: Aweys holds secret talks with Al-Shabaab
The leader of Somalia’s Hizbul Islam, Sheikh Hassan Dahir Aweys has secretly held talks with some top Al-Shabaab officials to discuss the brewing row between the two groups.

Confidential sources told Garowe Online that the meeting was tense with Al-Shabaab officials asking Sheikh Aweys to join them.

“The Hizbul Islam leader was pressured to resign from his post and join Al-Shabaab, but he decided to take time and think about it,” said one of Sheikh Aweys’s advisers who requested anonymity.

The official said top Hizbul Islam official are planning to meet next week to discuss about the Al-Shabaab demands over their leader.

The two groups, which are jointly involved in arm struggle against the embattled UN-backed Somali government, have broke ranks in recent past after they disputed over the control of Kismayo, a lucrative southern port city that is source for insurgence activities across the war-torn.

The fight over KIsamyo has also affected the relation between Sheikh Aweys and his deputy Sheikh Hassan Turki.

Speaking in Nairobi, Sheikh Abdinassir Serar, the group’s Foreign Affairs Secretary accused Aweys of being impediment, adding that the group will soon take stand against him.


As Michael Weinstein had noted in his October 27 analysis,

Another reported split in H.I. is between its chair, Sh. Hasan Dahir Aweys, and its former chair, Dr. Omar Iman, whom Aweys has supposedly accused of leaning too far toward H.S.M. and who is reportedly trying to mediate between H.S.M. and H.I.

Friday, November 13, 2009

Somalia thread for the week ending November 15

Xinhua: UN Somalia office to relocate to Mogadishu
Deputy UN special envoy to Somalia Charles Petrie yesterday during a previously unannounced brief visit to the Somali capital Mogadishu said the UN Somalia office currently based in Nairobi, Kenya, will be relocated to the Somali capital.

The UN envoy held meetings with Somali Prime Minister Omar Abdurashid Ali Sharmarkeh and the two officials discussed various issues including the relocating and reopening of the UN Somalia office in Mogadishu, Abdelkadir Walaayo, spokesman for the Somali government, said.

"The UN envoy promised that the office of the United Nations for Somalia will be moved from Nairobi to Mogadishu as soon as possible," Walaayo told reporters in Mogadishu.

Walaayo said the UN deputy envoy told Somali government officials that a senior UN official will be appointed for UN office in Mogadishu.


May just be a translation-related grammatical gaff, but Shabelle Media is reporting that Walaayo said he was told he was getting that appointment
The spokesman said that the official took part the meeting of the transitional cabinet which took place in Mogadishu today and led by the Somali Prime Minister Omar Abdirashid Ali Sharma’arke adding that Mr. Charles Patria said he would be appointed as a high official of the UN Security Council for the Somalia.


-- -- --

Press Release from the Republic of Seychelles, November 11

Seychelles and EU sign S.O.F.A
Joint statement by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the British High Commission- representing the European Union

Seychelles and the European Union have signed a Status of Forces Agreement this morning which established the legal status of foreign military and civilian personnel participating in the framework of the EU Military Operation Atalanta. This Agreement will provide legal basis to the deployment of the European Union-led Forces (EUNAVFOR) units and personnel in the territory of the Republic of Seychelles.

...

The signature of the Status of Forces Agreement with EU agreement will formally authorize EUNAVFOR units and personnel to pursue pirates and armed robbers from the high seas to the territorial sea, the archipelagic and internal waters of Seychelles and to use necessary force, including the right to arrest and detain persons.
On the other hand, the agreement makes provisions for the usual privileges and immunities to the EUNAVFOR personnel and units such as exemption from visa regulations and freedom of movement within our territory as per the norms of international military agreements.

The SOFA also builds on an exchange of letters between Minister Morgan, and Mr. Javier Solana, Secretary General/ High representative of the Council of the European Union on the subject of the modalities for the arrest, prosecution and transfer of persons involved in piracy.

...

The Status of Forces Agreement with EU also follows a similar agreement signed with US and France to enable enhanced surveillance activities against piracy.


-- -- --

European Voice: Support for training Somali security forces
Ministers to back training mission in Uganda.

EU foreign ministers are on Tuesday (17 November) to endorse a plan to train several thousand Somali security forces in Uganda. It will become an EU mission, running in parallel to the EU's anti-piracy mission operating off the coast of Somalia.

Member states' ambassadors on the political and security committee of the Council of Ministers yesterday (11 November) agreed a text inviting the Union's foreign policy chief to start operational planning for the training mission. The text includes broad outlines of the training mission, which is fraught with difficulties because the new security forces are supposed to absorb clan fighters and Islamist militias.

The European Commission is worried that Somalia has no functioning government that could guarantee financing for security forces. Under current rules, EU money cannot be used to pay the wages of security forces, but providing military training to militia members risks undermining the government unless there is a guarantee that they can be paid in the future.

Only two governments – the United States and Italy – provide direct financing to Somali government forces. The international community pledged at a donors' conference in April to support the training of a 10,000-strong Somali police force and a national army of around 5,000 men.


-- -- --

IPS: Rendition Redux?
On the heels of a federal appeals court ruling that only the U.S. Congress and the executive branch of government - not the courts - can interfere with government-sponsored "extraordinary rendition", a U.S. citizen from New Jersey is asking another court to tell the government it wasn't okay to secretly imprison and abuse him in three different African countries over a period of four months.

The citizen is Amir Meshal, 24, the son of Muslim immigrants from Egypt. According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which filed the lawsuit in Meshal's behalf, after fleeing hostilities in Somalia in 2006, Meshal was arrested, secretly imprisoned in inhumane conditions and subjected to harsh interrogations by U.S. officials over 30 times in three different countries before ultimately being released four months later without charge,

"This case challenges the U.S. government's effort to evade accountability for illegal detention and interrogations in counterterrorism operations by masking and hiding its involvement," Jonathan Hafetz, a staff attorney with the ACLU National Security Project, told IPS.

According to the ACLU, Meshal was studying Islam in Mogadishu, Somalia, in December 2006, when hostilities broke out. With the airport disabled by bombing, Meshal fled to neighboring Kenya, where he wandered in the forest for three weeks seeking shelter and assistance before being arrested.

Following his arrest, he was detained and repeatedly interrogated by U.S. officials who threatened to harm him, denied him access to counsel and accused him of receiving training from al Qaeda, which Meshal denied.

Following his arrest and detention in Kenya, the suit says Meshal was illegally rendered to Somalia and then to Ethiopia where he was imprisoned in secret for over three months. There, U.S. officials allegedly subjected him to harsh interrogations while denying him due process and access to a lawyer, his family or anyone else in the outside world.

"The harsh treatment and mental anguish this individual suffered should never be experienced by anyone, let alone an American citizen at the hands of his own government," said Hafetz. "This violation of basic constitutional rights must be remedied."

Court filings say that during his detention, Meshal was kept in "filthy, crowded conditions in cells infested with cockroaches and given inadequate access to food, water and toilets. While in Kenya, the Americans who interrogated him repeatedly threatened him with torture."

"The interrogators warned Meshal that he could be sent to Somalia or Egypt, where the Egyptians 'had ways of making him talk', if he refused to answer questions or agree to the interrogators' allegations. Meshal was also threatened with being sent to Israel, where, the interrogators said, the Israelis would "make him disappear," the papers charge.

At least one consular affairs official from the U.S. Embassy in Nairobi met with Meshal and was aware of his detention, but later claimed he lost contact with Meshal following his rendition to Ethiopia. Meshal was finally released in May 2007 with no additional explanation.

"This is a U.S. citizen who was caught in hostilities abroad, and instead of helping him return, U.S. officials abused him and mistreated him and never charged him with a crime," said Nusrat Choudhury, one of the lead lawyers from the ACLU representing Meshal. "Should they be allowed to do that without helping a U.S. citizen get home, and instead, denying him access to lawyers?"

The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia against two agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and two other unnamed U.S. government officials.


-- -- --

Ecoterra Intl: Owners Of Weapons Ship In Efforts TO Cover Up
...

Confusion about the weapons find on MV ALMEZAAN was also created, because on Sunday the African Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) reportedly received a "military consignment" for its troops in Mogadishu and harbour workers were told to "remain behind the barbed wire until the unloading of the consignment is through” said Yussuf Ahmed a worker in the seaport while speaking to local radio, adding that it would be usual to halt the activities at the seaport whenever there is a military consignment offloaded from a ship which is carrying military equipment for the African Union troops in Somalia.
Early reports about the weapons ship at Garacad therefore had even triggered frantic calls by TFG officials into Hobyo and Garacad claiming that the weapons on the seized vessel were for the Somali government.

But others also seem to be interested in the clandestine cargo of MV ALMEZAAN, because a heavily armed Al-Shebaab convoy from Mogadishu has arrived yesterday in the area.

Meanwhile it transpired that the owner of the vessel from Dubai called the captors and cautioned them against revealing anything about the cargo.

Thereby a similar saga seems to evolve as during the previous event, when the same vessel was briefly captured on May 1, 2009 about 60 nm off Mogadishu and first reports directly from the captured ship spoke of a consignment, which also comprised of some armoured vehicles with UN logo. Also back then a frantic effort ensued to cover up and to come to a quick arrangement with the captors. Is it too far fetched to assume that those vehicles might have been the ones used in the double suicide bombing of the AU headquarters in Mogadishu? The UN and FBI investigations into the origin of those vehicles has not been released.

Why has the UN, who unisono (sic) with the US and the transitional federal government of Somalia persistently claimed that e.g. Eritrea would deliver weapons to the Islamic insurgents in Somalia, not a single time achieved to impound a single of the illegal weapons transports - despite the fact that a whole global armada watches the Somali coasts. Apparently already some of the deadly cargo from MV ALMEZAAN has been offloaded.

If one leaves cases like this just to the media-spin of easily intimidated Somali journalists with access to the wires, also this case will be solve "the Somali way", which not necessarily provides for more transparency and peace or less weapons in the country.


also

Ship at Somali coast was carrying arms, says Somali official
An anti-piracy official in Somalia's transitional government said on Wednesday that a cargo ship seized at the weekend by pirates had been carrying weapons, a charge denied by the owners of the ship's cargo.

"On November 7 a cargo ship carrying a wide range of weapons was seized by Somali buccaneers," said the official, Ismail Haji Noor, in a statement.

He said he had informed the EU's anti-piracy operation, Atalanta, of the capture of the ship and about "the unfortunate possibility that the captors themselves could now offload the weapons and bring them to shore - to either use or sell them".

He said that despite his warning, no naval vessel in the area had sailed to Garacad, where the "weapons ship" is now moored, to investigate or prevent the arms from being offloaded.


Now is this the same "Ismail Haji Noor" that was involved in at least two propaganda stories back in March, which I followed here? Or is it a different character altogether who just happens to share the same name? As "Special Envoy for Anti-Piracy from the Somali governmental side [who] was appointed and serves also as liaison to the international navies", Noor has been showing up in the media more regularly.

-- -- --

While not specifically dealing with Somalia, I'm throwing these two VOA reports and some related links into the mix

Ethiopia's Meles says US at Fault for Africa's Econ Woes
Ethiopia Prime Minister Meles Zenawi says failures in the U.S. financial system are largely to blame for Africa's economic crisis, and pointed to China as a possible key to recovery. Our correspondent in Addis Ababa has details of the Ethiopian leader's keynote address to the annual African Economic Conference.

...

Mr. Meles, a former Marxist rebel leader, launched a blistering attack on what he called "discredited neo-liberal economic policies" imposed on Africa from outside. He said unsustainable consumption by the United States when times were good had condemned Africa to a protracted period of low growth ahead.

"The United States has hitherto served as the consumer of last resort and helped to maintain the unsustainable division of labor and division of production and consumption," he said. "It is no longer able to do it, and this is the main cause of the current crisis."

Mr. Meles suggested Africa's best hope might be a massive infusion of cash from China and other countries that have amassed surplus savings by producing goods for the consumers.

"It is possible to imagine that the Chinese will decided to redirect some of their surplus savings to infrastructural development in Africa," said Meles Zenawi. "It is possible to do so because to some extent it is already happening. Such a shift would mean tens of billions of dollars per annum invested in African infrastructure, again opening the opportunity for the transformation of the overall economy. Indeed, it is not only possible but highly probable that the Chinese will take steps that would widen the window of opportunity for Africa."


Skeptic At African Econ Meeting Questions Benefits of Development Aid
A leading development aid skeptic has told a conference of African economists and academics the key to ending poverty in Africa is not better development strategies but greater individual liberty.

New York University Professor William Easterly stunned a conference dedicated to fostering development in Africa by saying, for the most part, development strategies don't work.

...

Ethiopia's Prime Minister Meles Zenawi argued in his keynote address that African governments had been doing 'rather well' with poverty reduction strategies until the economic crisis hit last year.

Easterly counters that planners and strategists would do better to listen to the crowds of small and medium sized businesses that have traditionally been the engine of economic growth. He says the best plan is to have no plan. "I think way too much effort is wasted on the overall development strategy. Now does that mean there's nothing professionals and experts can do. No. I don't say that. What we learned from what we observe in successful development is that they depend not on the wisdom of a single individual but on the wisdom of the crowds. The crowds of entrepreneurs, political entrepreneurs, economic private sectors entrepreneurs, social entrepreneurs, aid entrepreneurs," he said.

Easterly is something of an odd man out at this conference of economic planners. He is author of two provocative books that examine why the more than $700 billion spent on foreign aid in Africa over the past 50 years has done so little to promote sustainable growth.

He says the main cause of poor performance is that most strategies are designed by foreign experts rather than by the people themselves. "One thing in common to all success is that they are all home grownprograms. They did not give power to outside experts. The guidance of the program was homegrown and not driven by foreign experts," he said.

Many conference participants expressed doubt home grown development schemes could thrive in Africa, where authoritarian regimes are commonplace and investors are wary. Easterly agrees it would be difficult to build a prosperous society in the absence of economic freedom. "In the long run, it does seem to be both necessary and sufficient to have political and economic liberty to achieve broad based development," he said.

Easterly said the record is clear that small and medium-sized businesses generate the jobs and demand that lift countries out of poverty.


Observations from a couple of Easterly's September posts on his blog, Aid Watch

How the British Invented “Development” to Keep the Empire and Substitute for Racism
During the early years of World War II, Japan won major victories (such as the capture of Singapore) against the British and threatened India. Japanese propaganda pointed to British racism and offered themselves as the defenders of non-white peoples. The British feared that non-white people in the colonies might side with the Japanese rather than their colonial masters. The British had to come up with a new justification for colonial rule to replace the unpopular and increasingly implausible idea that they were a superior race destined to rule inferior races. In response, they invented the concept of economic development.

This story is told in an undeservedly obscure book by Suke Wolton, 2000, Lord Hailey, the Colonial Office, and the Politics of Race and Empire in the Second World War..

...

Of course, changing the language from racist to economic development did not mean racism suddenly disappeared. As Wolton shows, “the white Western elites still believed in their fundamental superiority.” In the end, Wolton says, “The major powers would continue to be able to determine the future of the colonial territories – only this time the source of their legitimacy was based less on racial difference and more on their new role as protector and developmental economist.” After the war, even more officials went out to the Empire in what became known as the “second colonial occupation.”

Why does this history matter today? After all, the Empire fell apart much sooner than expected, and racism did diminish a lot over time. And I do NOT mean to imply guilt by association for development as imperialist and racist; there are many theories of development and many who work on development (including many from developing countries themselves) that have nothing to do with imperialism and racism.

But I think the origin of development as cover for imperialism and racism did have toxic legacies for some. First, it meant that the concept of development was determined to fit a propaganda imperative; it was NOT a breakthrough in thought by economists. Second, it followed that development from the beginning would stress the central role of Western aid to help the helpless natives (which shows up in the early development theories like the “poverty trap” and the “Big Push,” and the lack of interest in local entrepreneurs and market incentives). Third, the paternalism was so extreme at the beginning that it would last for a long time – I still think it is widespread today, especially after today’s comeback of the early development ideas in some parts of the aid system. And this history also seems strangely relevant with today’s “humanitarian” nouveau-imperialism to invade and fix “failed states” like Iraq and Afghanistan.


The Imperial Origins of State-Led Development
Lenin said “Imperialism is the Last Stage of Capitalism.” Globalization protesters routinely link American imperialism to promotion of capitalism overseas. For example, Naomi Klein’s 2008 book The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism draws a vivid connection between American interventions overseas (like the CIA overthrowing Allende in Chile, or today’s Iraq) and the promotion of free markets (“neoliberal economics”).

It’s plausible that there are sometimes connections between military interventions and the economic interests of the intervener. Yet it is not so obvious that imperialism promotes free markets. Historically, the most egregious imperialism, such as the British Empire, actually promoted state-led development rather than free markets.

...

What about imperialism and attitudes toward development today? One intriguing thing I wonder in the light of both today’s post, and yesterday’s post on colonial racism and paternalism, is the affection of today’s British public and academics for paternalistic and state-led theories of development somehow related to the British colonial past? As compared to the lack of sympathy for such theories among the American public and academics, when America lacks much of a colonial past and traditionally criticized colonialism?

Of course, the US has been no slouch as an imperialist lately. Yet today’s US imperialism does not obviously promote free markets. The US quickly abandoned a brief experiment with trying to create the perfect free market in Iraq (correctly derided by Naomi Klein) after the insurgency arose. Now in both Iraq and Afghanistan, there is heavy reliance on the aid-military-state complex to promote development. It is true that American companies have benefited from both interventions, but NOT from free market opportunities in either country. No, they grow fat on aid-government contracts.

So imperialism is not so clearly linked to capitalism and free markets after all; historically there has been a closer link between colonialism/imperialism and state-led approaches to development. People who like Imperialism are fond of a big military state presence, so it’s not so surprising that they are also fond of a big economic state presence.


Back to Meles...

Bloomberg: Meles Unites 52 Nations to Exert Clout at UN Summit
Africa’s point man at the Copenhagen climate-change summit next month is prime minister of drought- stricken Ethiopia, a former Marxist rebel who favors tailored suits and has coaxed billions of dollars in aid from the West.

...

Envoys for the Dec. 7-18 Copenhagen meeting were given a taste of Meles’s clout at climate talks in Barcelona last week when African delegates staged a one-day walkout to demand the developed world cut greenhouse-gas emissions by 40 percent. Meles has threatened a similar exodus at Copenhagen, which could derail an agreement as he’ll represent 52 of the 190 nations present when unanimity is always sought on global UN accords.

...

Meles demands industrialized countries such as the U.S. and Britain that released most of the historical emissions to compensate developing nations for climate damage they caused in recent decades. He also seeks subsidies to install clean-energy equipment. The cost to richer nations: $67 billion a year.

...

Meles may be the “ideal” climate negotiator for the continent, Rhoda Tumusiime, the African Union’s agriculture commissioner, said Oct. 20 from Uganda, citing his knowledge of the issues and dealings with the U.S., Europe and China.

“We believe he has the charisma to engage with these global powers,” Tumusiime said.

Search for African leaders in power long enough who have international credibility and technical knowledge of climate issues and “you come up with a very short list,” [David] Shinn said of Meles last month.

...

Meles has focused on the subject as the effects of climate change hit Ethiopia’s economy, which is dependent on rain-fed agriculture, said Negusu Aklilu, director of the Ethiopia-based Forum for the Environment.

...

The cigarette-smoking, tennis-playing Meles says he seeks to build a “lily-white capitalist system.” The government remains the largest force in Ethiopia’s economy, controlling ownership of all land, two-thirds of the banking system and monopolies in electricity, telecommunications and aviation.

After the terrorist attacks on New York and Washington on Sept. 11, 2001, Meles became a closer ally of the U.S., which provided intelligence and logistical support to Ethiopia’s two- year Horn of Africa war against Islamists in Somalia that ended with an Ethiopian withdrawal in January.

Ethiopia won $3.6 billion in debt relief from the World Bank and other donors in 2006 and receives more than $2 billion in aid annually from developed countries, who provide food aid for 13.7 million Ethiopians, about one-sixth of the population.

The U.S. trains the country’s army and provided some $850 million in aid last year, including 464,000 metric tons of food.

...

Asked what would happen if the African delegation walked out in Copenhagen like it did in Barcelona, Elliot Diringer, who oversees international strategies at the Pew Center on Global Climate Change, said that UN agreements are taken by consensus so “it would make a deal impossible. But that’s in no one’s interest so I wouldn’t expect it to come to that.”

As the rhetoric on climate change escalates ahead of the Copenhagen summit, Meles has “set himself up as the spokesman for Africa,” said Saleemul Huq, a researcher at the International Institute for Environment and Development. “The high-level decisions will filter through him.”


Two more...

The man who destroyed Somalia... Meles Zenawi
What you will read here is a clear predictable trends that is used against us to continue chaos in Somalia and never allow it to be a viable state among nations of the world. Unless we understand this trends we will never be able to come out of this hell-hole our enemies have dug for us.

Some of you are asking by now “ what are this predictable trends?”. My fellow Somalis it is a proven strategy that is been used all over the world for centuries to weaken nations and conquer them. The enemies of Somalia started using it soon after the Ethiopia-Somalia war of 1977. The British and the Italians used it quite effectively in Somalia during colonization. Simply put, our enemies have been quite effective in dividing us and arming us against one another. It's been happening for a longtime and it is about time we start to pay attention and inform ourselves on who is our friend and who is our enemy.

...

When a detective is investigating a murder, one of the questions he will ask himself to determine who killed the victim is “ who will benefit from the death of this person?”. So, lets put that questions to the case of Somalia. Who benefits or is interested in the permanent destruction of Somalia?. The list is long, but I will use the proactive ones in the Somali political sphere. Lets start with the case of Ethiopia and you will start to see a self reinforcing trend.

Ethiopia and Somalia went to war in 1977 over the Ogaden region. Ethiopia has over five million ethnic somali inhabitants in the Ogaden region, some of them are waging war against Ethiopia itself {ONLF}. Ethiopia is 50 percent muslim but always ruled by christian, so there is balance to be protected there by the christian rulers. Ethiopia is a landlocked country and planning to use port of Berbera for pennies on the dollar. Ethiopia is a loose nation by that I mean a collection of many tribes that can easily be fragmented. Ethiopia has a bitter enemy to north in the name of Eritrea and don't want a possible enemy in name of strong Somalia that has grievances against Ethiopia i.e Ogaden region.

By now we are starting to see Ethiopia is well happy with the current Somali situation as long as we keep fighting among ourselves Ethiopia will supply the weapons and if one group is getting the upper hand, he will be called a terrorist or Ethiopia will come in and crush him with its military. That is what they have been doing for the last 18 yrs. Arming all the groups with the same amount of weapons and if one is winning Ethiopia will decrease his share of arms and Ethiopia will increase his opponents share, so nobody wins and we will continue to be in a perpetual state of war.

The greatest strategist of the 21st century in Africa is Meles Zenawi. He was a rebel leader at the age of 27 and after few years overthrew the strongest military in Africa at that time. Meles is no fool and his potential future enemy is strong Somali republic to his east. He will do anything to keep that from ever becoming a reality. He will use every trick in the book to defame and defeat any viable group that wants to rule Somalia. You should ask this the former president Abdiqassim Salat Hassan. He will tell you it was Ethiopia that was sending weapons to various warlords to oppose his government for apparently no reason. Abdiqassim is not an extremist religious radical. So, why was Ethiopia against his government?. Simple, Ethiopia is safeguarding its self interest. Ethiopian policy is “no Somalia Government”. Now you know the trends. Even the TFG of Sheikh Sharif will be a victim. Ethiopia will find some excuse to secretly arm some group against it. But for now Ethiopia is happy with the dual between Alshabaab, and Ahlu Sunna and TFG. If Ahlu Sunna and the government are winning Ethiopia is not going to allow anyone to dominate Somalia, so Ethiopia will secretly start arming some Somali group against the government and chaos will continue. Ethiopia is so good at and they have done it so many times what I have mentioned in this article that their strategies became a predictable trends.

...

Ethiopia is currently arming and training Ahlu Sunna and forces loyal to the TFG. Ethiopia's cover story is Alshabab is a radical terrorist group. In reality Alshabab will not pose a serious threat to Ethiopia for at least 15 yrs because Somalia is such a destroyed country and international community will slap an arms embargo on Alshabab administration in Somalia anyway. But Ethiopia don't want to take the risk of any strong Somali government in the future. They rather have Somalia the way it is now and Ethiopia will make sure Somalia stays that way.

Ethiopia wants the complete disintegration of Somalia. Ethiopia prefers Somalia to be split into smaller states. The prove is, while Ethiopia is claiming to be helping the TFG on the other hand Ethiopia recognized the separatist region of Somaliland. As a matter of fact Ethiopia accepts Somaliland issued passport that is enough sign that Ethiopia recognises Somaliland as a sovereign country with its national flag. What a double standard. Ethiopia is currently in negotiation with Hargeisa over planned use of port of Berbera by Ethiopians. Ethiopia is running away from Djibouti port because Djibouti recently raised taxation and fees on Ethiopian goods passing through Djiboutian ports. And both Djibouti and Somaliland are Somalis. That is how Ethiopia wants, divided people.


And

West oppresses Ethiopia through Zenawi support
‘No alternative in the opposition,’ they whispered anonymously. What a disgusting phrase to use in justifying support for a ruthless dictatorship. That is apparently the scuttlebutt on Embassy Row in Addis Ababa. Reuters’ Barry Malone reported last week, ‘Most Western governments want Meles to continue because there is no alternative in the opposition. As long as the elections are semi-democratic, they'll probably stay quiet, keep giving aid, hope for liberalisation of the economy and leave full democracy for later.’ Is this the ultimate proof of the triumph of Western moral relativism, hypocrisy and skullduggery in Ethiopia and Africa? Is this the new 21st century Western paradigm of moral capitulation and appeasement of evil? Is the West going to a moral hellhole in a hand basket?

We now have a clear answer to a question that had puzzled us for the past two decades: Why do Western governments and their multilateral lending institutions support Zenawi’s dictatorship with billions of dollars in loans and foreign aid? Answer: Because ‘there is no alternative in the opposition!’ Why do they turn a blind eye to the gross violations of human rights in Ethiopia? Turn a deaf ear to the bootless cries of the thousands of Ethiopian political prisoners rotting in Zenawi’s jail? Pretend to be mute on Birtukan Midekssa’s unjust imprisonment? Prop up a regime that ruthlessly decimates its opposition, crushes the free press, chokes civil society organisations, squanders and defalcates foreign aid and loans and lords imperiously over a famine-ravaged country? Why do ‘most Western governments want Meles to continue?’ Answer: ‘Because there is no alternative in the opposition!’

It is agonising to finally come face to face with the banality of depraved Western diplomatic indifference in Addis Ababa. It is heartbreaking to learn that Western governments have earnestly resolved to humanise and normalise a brutal regime while preaching to Africans in forked tongue that their dictators are on the wrong side of morality and history. They shed crocodile tears for the victims of African dictators. They comfort the helpless and frightened African masses with sweet words of hope and grand promises of democratic renaissance. Now we have come to find out that the hypocrites are secretly in bed with the very dictators they condemn in public! It must be true that ‘politics makes for strange bedfellows.’

The ‘no alternative in the opposition’ Western diplomatic mantra and mindset could have devastating consequences on Ethiopia and other African countries suffering under the stranglehold of dictatorial rule. It means the seeds of the rule of law will die on the barren soil of African dictatorships; that totalitarianism and police states are morally justified and compelled in Africa whenever Western governments conclude there are ‘no alternatives in the opposition’; that state-sponsored violence and repression are necessary moral imperatives for the nurturance of an ‘emerging democracy’; and that dictatorship is necessary to save Ethiopians, and Africans in general, from themselves. Simply stated, the triumph of dictatorship in Africa is a necessary precondition for the rapture of democracy in Africa. Such has become the pitiful logic of moral decay and duplicity of Western governments in Africa today!

Of course, the whole notion of ‘no alternative in the opposition’ is absurd and patently false in its premise and conclusion. There is definitely a viable alternative in the opposition in Ethiopia, but Zenawi ruthlessly eliminates and roots out any opposition before it poses a real challenge to him.


There's much more in that commentary by the Professor-slash-lawyer Alemayehu Mariam and this hypocrisy & duplicity he correctly points out are, of course, nothing new. In the politics of US foreign policy, support for dictators and authoritarianism has been generally viewed as a prerequisite to fostering the stability needed for programs compatible with foreign interests, typically centered around extractables and economic growth, though there are geostrategic aims as well. During the decades of the cold war, for example, US support for allied dictators was ideologically justified as being beneficial for the peoples under that regime since it prevented repressive leftist dictators from coming to power, in which case, the premise went, it would be virtually guaranteed that there'd be no openings for "democracy" to take root.

So to bring this back to Meles and exit the topic (for now) on an interesting note, from the 1991 NYT article, Rebels Who Shed Marxist Rigidity,

The notion that the rebels' early affiliation with Marxism is an insignificant predictor of how they will govern is shared by senior United States officials who say that now is an excellent time to midwife a new nation, since communist ideology is in disrepute with the collapse of the Soviet empire.

One official also described Mr. Meles as "someone who understands Western political thought."


-- -- --

SMC: Islamists denounce Puntland for Extraditing Somalis to Ethiopia
The Islamist administration in the southern seaport town of Kismayo has denounced the authority of the semi-autonomous state in eastern Somalia, for extraditing Somalis in their region.

The spokesman of Al-Shabab in the southern regions in Somalia Sheikh Hassan Yakub has expressed their concept towards extraditing Somalis to the Ethiopian regime.

“Where ever people are ruled in rules which are not the based in the Holy Quran, the authority of that particular place can deal with the citizens under their authority which ever way they want to do, the so called authority of Puntland has extradited number of Somali youths, and elders to the government of Abyssinia, and that act is absolutely contrary against the Islamic Sharia Law” said Sheikh Hassan Yakub the spokesman of Al-Shabab in the Jubbah regions.

The spokesman has also added in his speech that their faction is not in any way involved in the recent instability in some parts of Puntland.

“There are some people pretending to part of the wide network of Al-Shabab who are carrying out operations which have recently created instability in the some parts of Eastern Somalia, we are strongly warning these people to stop the wild acts they are carrying out in that region, and they are not intending to abstain those evil acts we shall take measures against them” added Sheikh Yakub.

This speech from the administration of Al-Shabab coincides at a time when there has been instability in the semi-autonomous region of Puntland in the past couple of weeks.


Another report adds
“We know that Puntland authorities jailed more young Somali Muslims who are secretly tortured in custodies while many more were handed over to Ethiopia under the Christian-funded campaign of fight against terrorism which is intended to eradiate Muslims around the world” the Islamist spokesman said.

He called on the residents in Puntland regions to organize uprisings against the government and refuse what he described as the animosity against Islam by the regional government.

“Allah doesn’t watch over those harassing his Muslim followers and we hope that Allah will punish the puppet administrators in Puntland who are killing, arresting and extraditing the innocent Muslims” the militant spokesperson stated.


-- -- --

Daily Nation: Kenya warned against courting militia
Kenya could be sucked into the Somalia conflict unless the recruitment of youths to take part in the war stops, analysts have warned.

Rashid Abdi, the Horn of Africa analyst for the International Crisis Group, told the Sunday Nation that the drive to prop up the Transitional Federal Government (TFG) in Mogadishu risks destabilising the North Eastern Province which has enjoyed relative peace for the past 15 years.

Al Shabaab militants, who some say have links with international terrorist groups, last week threatened they would hit targets in Kenya unless the government stops supporting the TFG. A parliamentary team has been set up to investigate reports that Kenyan youths are being recruited to fight against the Islamist militia.

On Saturday, members of the Defence committee visited the Manyani training camp at the Coast where it has been reported that the youth are receiving training before being dispatched to Somalia. “There appears to have been a major security breach that has occurred on Kenyan soil,” said committee chairman Adan Keynan.

The MP for Wajir West said they had received credible reports that up to 48 youths who had been in the camp were moved out on Friday night in anticipation of the committee’s visit.

“It is becoming clear that Kenya has taken sides in this war, which is very serious for us because we are a frontline state and share a long and porous border with Somalia,” he said.

...

Mr Abdi said Kenya should keep out: “The fact we are stepping in to back the TFG shows the fragile nature of the administration and might give the Al Shabaab reason to retaliate against Kenya. “It is a sign of desperation because the TFG has failed to win legitimacy from the people and faces a major challenge from the Islamists who have an advantage in the unconventional war that is the Somalia conflict.”


-- -- --

Pittsburgh Tribune-Reivew: Pittsburgh native tracks Somali pirates
DJIBOUTI CITY — Pittsburgh native Lt. Nicholas Rueda, 28, commands a P-3 Orion, the Navy plane used during the Cold War to track Russian submarines.

Today, his P-3 operates as a maritime-patrol aircraft, searching for Somali pirates in the Gulf of Aden and the Indian Ocean off the coasts of Djibouti and Somalia.

...

The joint U.S. base here has become a key staging point for U.S. forces battling elusive but daring modern-day pirates.

...

He is not permitted to discuss any sightings of pirates, but he says "we know exactly where the pirate ships are."

...

"We are typically going out, taking a look at where we know they are and what kind of daily routines they are going through," he explains. "That may help down the road, if some actions are ... taken against the pirates."

...

Rear Adm. Anthony Kurta, who commands the joint U.S. task force here, says his force works with Djibouti, Kenya and Tanzania on a comprehensive anti-piracy strategy.

"It is not just building a navy or coast guard to go after them," he says. "It's also helping with their legal structure — anti-piracy laws, the ability of their courts and prosecutors to handle pirates if they are apprehended.

"I think there is a realization that the long-term solution to piracy doesn't lay with the ships offshore, but in ... [nation-building...] the creation of a functioning, stable government in Somalia that provides some economic opportunity other than folks resorting to something like piracy."


From an analysis at Stratfor around the time of the Seychelles visit in August

P-3Cs and Counterpiracy Operations
A U.S. Navy P-3C Orion maritime patrol aircraft landed in the Seychelles on Aug. 12 for a one-day visit. Orions and other maritime patrol aircraft from the United States — as well as aircraft from Spain, Germany, France and Japan — are operating from Djibouti and Kenya to support counterpiracy operations in the Gulf of Aden and the Indian Ocean.

...

The Orion has proven to be a remarkably versatile platform, and has been one of the most in-demand U.S. military aircraft recently — not for sea service, but by ground combat forces in Iraq and Afghanistan.

The aircraft’s wealth of sensor equipment (particularly the forward-looking infrared, or FLIR, system mounted on the aircraft’s chin) and long loiter time make it an attractive platform for counterinsurgency operations where a high level of tactical situational awareness and extended time on station are critical. Ground combat commanders have even used P-3s as airborne command posts. P-3 crews who deploy to Iraq may not even get a chance to practice maritime surveillance or anti-submarine operations because of their operational tempo ashore.

...

Not only can the P-3 and other land-based maritime patrol aircraft loiter at higher altitude and monitor a wider area, but also Orions are armed with a variety of ordnance. The Orion’s armament includes Harpoon anti-ship missiles and more traditional naval weapons like torpedoes and mines as well as AGM-65 Maverick guided missiles, which would be more effective against smaller craft.


Technical data on the P-3C from the P-3 Orion Research Group
Lockheed Martin P-3C Orion armament
(up to around 20,000 pounds internal and external loads)

bomb bay
eight MK46/50 torpedoes
eight MK54 depth bombs
three MK36/52 1000 lb mines
three MK57 depth bombs
two MK101 depth bombs
one MK25/39/55/56 2000 lb mines


two center-section pylons
two AGM-84 Harpoon anti ship missiles
two AGM-65 Maverick air-to-surface guided missiles
two MK46/50 torpedoes
two 2000 lb mines
four MK20 Rockeye cluster bombs


three under outer wing pylons
(per wing, inboard to outboard)
two MK46/50 torpedoes or 1000 lb mines
two MK46/50 torpedoes or 1000 lb mines or rockets
two MK46/50 torpedoes or 500 lb mines or rockets
three MK20 Rockeye cluster bombs


A total maximum weapon load includes:
six 2000 lb mines under wings
two MK101 depth bombs
four MK50 torpedoes
87 sonobuoys
pyrotechnics, signals


WRT the other hunter/killer drone that AFRICOM is moving onstage into the theater, The East African reports that Crawley alluded to scope creep entailing land-based counterinsurgency operations:

We won’t arm drones in East African waters – US
The United States has “no plans” to arm the pilotless aircraft that are carrying out reconnaissance missions from a base in the Seychelles, a spokesman of the US Africa Command (Africom) has said.

The aerial surveillance vehicles, known as MQ-9 Reaper drones, “will be operating primarily over water,” spokesman Vince Crawley told The EastAfrican in an email from Africom headquarters in Stuttgart, Germany.

He was reacting to a story carried in this newspaper last week: “Armed drones to pursue pirates off the Horn”

But he did not rule out other missions for the long-range drones, including flights over Somalia to track Islamist militants fighting to overthrow a government backed by the US, the United Nations and the African Union.

Mr Crawley said deployment of the drones reflects “a commitment to counter-piracy, maritime security, border security, deterrence of international terrorism, and other security-related issues impacting the residents of Seychelles and neighbouring countries.”

...

The governments of the United States and Seychelles agreed after several months of discussions to base what Mr Crawley describes as “intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance” assets at Mahé regional airport.

About 75 US government personnel are in the Seychelles to help carry out the mission, Mr Crawley said.

With a cruising speed of about 200 knots and a range of more than 3,500 nautical kilometres, the Reaper drones represent “an ideal platform for observing the vast ocean and maritime corridors in the Indian Ocean region and assisting in counter-piracy efforts,” Mr Crawley continued.

The operation could make use of other intelligence-gathering options in addition to the Reapers, he said without specifying those options.

He emphasised, however, that these “assets will not be armed, and we have no plans of doing so.”

The Reaper class of drones can carry several guided bombs and missiles.

The Reapers are more powerful than the drones known as MQ-1 Predators that are regularly used by the US to strike targets in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

...

The Seychelles-based mission is expected to last several months as Africom assesses its effectiveness, Mr Crawley said.


-- -- --

IPS: U.S., Somalia Still Opt Out of Children's Treaty
When the U.N. children's agency (UNICEF) commemorates the 20th anniversary of its landmark international treaty protecting the rights of children next week, there will be two countries skipping the celebrations: the United States and Somalia.

"It is embarrassing to find ourselves in the company of Somalia, a lawless land," presidential candidate Barack Obama said last year during his election campaign.

The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), which was adopted unanimously by the United Nations back in 1989, will be 20 years old on Nov. 20.

Described as the world's most rapidly and universally ratified human rights treaty, the Convention has been ratified by 193 states.

But the only two countries that have not ratified the treaty have nothing in common.

"Somalia is understandable," Kul Gautam, a former U.N. assistant secretary-general and ex-UNICEF deputy executive director, told IPS.

It has been a failed state without an effective government for over two decades, he added.

"But the United States does have a functioning government, which claims to be a great champion of human rights in the world. It baffles non-Americans, and even many Americans, as to why the U.S. is reluctant to ratify this Convention," Gautam added.